Relative Performance of Gold Stocks

The quarterly meeting of the Incrementum Fund’s Advisory Board took place earlier this month (April 12), and as usual, a special guest was invited to participate. This time we were joined by well-known fund manager John Hathaway (Toqueville Gold Fund). It was a very wide-ranging discussion of the financial markets and the economy, and we hope you will agree with us that it was quite interesting (as always, a PDF containing the transcript is available for download below).


Fund manager John Hathaway, special guest at the Incrementum Advisory Board Meeting this quarter.


One of the issues discussed by John we personally found particularly interesting was his idea as to why gold stocks have exhibited such dismal performance relative to gold this year. This has happened despite the fact that nearly all intermediate and senior producers are run by new managers who seem to be doing a great many things right. One would think that with the new-found focus on cost control and capital discipline, the sector should actually outperform rather than underperform precious metals.

Undoubtedly there are a number of factors playing into this, but John believes that particularly flows into and out of leveraged and unleveraged sector ETFs are exercising an outsized influence. This does certainly ring true to us. Consider for instance the major rebalancing of GDXJ that was implemented in 2017.

The ETF had become unable to properly fulfill its tracking function as many of its component stocks simply didn’t have sufficient trading volume. Moreover, the ETF had become so large, it held more than 10% of the issued share capital in some companies. The rebalancing was terrible news for the share prices of companies about to be removed from the ETF – their shares underperformed the sector quite a bit until the exercise was finally bedded down (this happened during a period of sector-wide weakness to boot).

What we were not aware of is that the leveraged ETFs may be an even more important driver in this context. Of course the same thing that exacerbates underperformance in times when interest in the sector wanes also exacerbates outperformance when the sector is back in fashion, such as in the first half of 2016. In the long run it should all balance out, but it is still important to be aware of this, as it inter alia means that one has to be cautious about the “signaling function” of the HUI/gold ratio. We will have more on this in our next gold update.


Leveraged and unleveraged gold junior ETFs – the tails wagging the dog


John inter alia also shared a few of his picks with us, and we think he has the right idea: senior producers are likely to look for acquisitions sooner or later, as reserve replacement is becoming quite an issue for many of them. At the moment there is a strong focus on brownfield exploration and expansion, but eventually the desire to buy out companies that have made enticing discoveries will return (per experience at a time when prices have already moved up quite a bit). Given the current phase of undervaluation and neglect, there are a number of opportunities out there (patience will be required, but we believe it will be well rewarded down the road).


Stock Market Signals

One more thing we wanted to briefly remark on here – because after reading the transcript it occurred to us that it might not come across the way we intended it to – are leading signals for the stock market. Regular readers are probably well aware by now that we have devoted quite a bit of effort to looking into this issue, based on the idea that the “QE” era (now morphing into the “QT” era) has created a number of unique market distortions.

Not only that, but the markets are also subject to structural problems that did not exist before. In fact, the effect of gold sector ETF flows on the performance of gold stocks is an excellent example of such a structural problem, albeit a relatively small and unimportant one compared to e.g. the proliferation of bond ETFs and assorted systematic trading strategies.

At one juncture we briefly address initial unemployment claims, which have a well-known negative correlation to the stock market and have occasionally served as a short term leading indicator of major trend changes. The main point we wanted to make in this context is that one can simply not rely on such indicators giving timely warning signals.

Whether it is the trend in margin debt, the A/D line, unemployment claims or even more firmly anchored (from both a theoretical and empirical perspective) signals such as credit spreads, one has to be mentally prepared for being surprised –  as opposed to getting the usual combination of early warning signals that historically tended to ring the bell at major market tops and bottoms. So this is what we meant to convey.


NYSE margin debt – it is widely held that it always peaks ahead of major stock market tops, but we have found out this isn’t quite true. In 1937 it lagged stocks by one month, in 1973 it lagged them by 7 months – two of the worst bear markets in history followed.


This time we believe there will be more surprised than usual, but we can of course not prove this – it is just an educated guess. How precisely things will play out will only be known in hindsight.


Markets Underestimate “QT”

Lastly, the title of the transcript alludes to the fact that the markets appear to be underestimating the effect of the Fed’s passive “QT” operation, which consists of it no longer reinvesting the proceeds from maturing bonds in its portfolio (with the monthly amounts growing every quarter). Since “QE” has created a lot of deposit money (in addition to bank reserves – see for a detailed discussion of the mechanics here: “Can the Fed Print Money?”), it follows that “QT” will end up doing the opposite.


The decrease in assets held by the Fed is accelerating, but remains actually well behind plan at this point (this is mainly due to a technical issue in connection with agency bonds and mortgage  prepayments).


In other words, the markets and the economy are increasingly deprived of liquidity. An important point to keep in mind is that the private sector now not only has to fund the renewed acceleration in government deficit spending and the still ongoing expansion in corporate debt, but will also have to retroactively fund old debt that will no longer be bought by the Fed when it is rolled over.

This can only be counteracted by bank credit expansion, but banks are a bit hamstrung by the stricter regulations on capital adequacy introduced in the wake of the GFC. European banks in particular are still weighed down by nearly €1 trillion in NPLs to boot (and their US subsidiaries traditionally do play a considerable role in US domestic credit expansion; European banks are also big players in dollar funding markets overseas and in certain sectors such as commodity-related financing).

Anyway, the upshot is that it will become increasingly difficult to keep all the bubble plates in the air, so to speak.

A lot more was discussed during the meeting – below is the download link for the transcript. Enjoy!


Download Link:

Incrementum Advisory Board CC, Q2 2018 – Markets Underestimate QT (PDF)


Charts by: StockCharts, SentimenTrader, St. Louis Fed




Emigrate While You Can... Learn More




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


2 Responses to “Special Guest John Hathaway – Incrementum Advisory Board Meeting, Q2 2018”

  • All-Your-Gold-Are-Mine:

    Wow jks… what happened to you!? Yes, mining is a tough business reflected in the price of gold. However, not all stocks go to zero. Sorry this happened to you. You need to learn from your past experience and quit listening to those brokers and “promoters” that brought you the misfortune. Instead, learn to research yourself. You may not become an expert, but you will definitely be far more adept to finding analysts that have long histories of picking winners. There are many miners that were wildly successful. Not all management is equal. You could start by reading some books on that subject. Don’t be a whiner or a quitter – good luck!

  • jks:

    “…One of the issues discussed by John we personally found particularly interesting was his idea as to why gold stocks have exhibited such dismal performance relative to gold this year. This has happened despite the fact that nearly all intermediate and senior producers are run by new managers who seem to be doing a great many things right. One would think that with the new-found focus on cost control and capital discipline, the sector should actually outperform rather than underperform precious metals…”

    I can only speak for myself as a former junior miner investor. The sector is infested with the most aggressively dishonest cheats of any industry I’ve ever had the misfortune to deal with. The slime oozes from every pore, including the exchanges, the brokers, the clearing houses, the miners themselves, and especially the promoters that shill the stocks. If by some miracle you happen to own a mine that isn’t a hole with a liar at the top, there are worker strikes, OSHA attacks, EPA assaults and any number of other regulatory or legal quagmires that always seem to send the stock you own to zero no matter the price of the metal.

    Word gets around.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • How to Get Ahead in Today’s Economy
      “Literally On Fire” This week brought forward more evidence that we are living in a fabricated world. The popular story-line presents a world of pure awesomeness. The common experience, however,  falls grossly short.   There are many degrees of awesomeness, up to total awesomeness – which is where we are these days, in the age of total awesomeness, just a short skip away from the Nirvana era. What is Nirvana, you may wonder? We only know for sure that Nirvana is what...
  • Gold and Gold Stocks – Conundrum Alert
      Moribund Meandering Earlier this week, the USD gold price was pushed rather unceremoniously off its perch above the $1300 level, where it had been comfortably ensconced all year after its usual seasonal rally around the turn of the year. For a while it seemed as though the $1,300 level may actually hold, but persistent US dollar strength nixed that idea. Previously many observers (too many?) expected gold to finally break out from its lengthy consolidation pattern, but evidently the...
  • US Money Supply Growth Jumps in March , Bank Credit Growth Stalls
      A Movie We Have Seen Before – Repatriation Effect? There was a sizable increase in the year-on-year growth rate of the true US money supply TMS-2 between February and March. Note that you would not notice this when looking at the official broad monetary aggregate M2, because the component of TMS-2 responsible for the jump is not included in M2. Let us begin by looking at a chart of the TMS-2 growth rate and its 12-month moving average.   The y/y growth rate of TMS-2...
  • Fear and Longing - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Waiting for Permanent Backwardation  The price of gold dropped 9 bucks, while that of silver rose 3 cents. Readers often ask us if permanent backwardation (when gold withdraws its bid on the dollar) is still coming. We say it is certain (unless we can avert it by offering interest on gold at large scale). They ask is it imminent, and we think this is with a mixture of fear and longing for a higher gold price.   Lettuce hope this treasure is not cursed... but it probably is....
  • Scorn and Reverence - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Shill Alarm One well-known commentator this week opined about the US health care industry:   “...the system is designed the churn and burn... to push people through the clinics as quickly as possible. The standard of care now is to prescribe some medication (usually antibiotics) and send people on their way without taking the time to conduct a comprehensive examination.”   From the annals of modern health care... [PT]   Nope. That is not the standard...
  • Gold and Gold Stocks – The Gloom Patrol
      Fun with Positioning and Sentiment Last week we discussed the gold sector “conundrum” – the odd fact that there is apparently quite strong demand for gold despite a macroeconomic environment that would normally be considered quite bearish for the metal. Gold recently seems to have lost its last remaining inter-market “ally” if you will, as the dollar has begun to enter an uptrend as well. Positioning data in precious metals futures are nevertheless rather remarkable, given the...
  • Global Turn-of-the-Month Effect – An Update
      In Other Global Markets the “Turn-of-the-Month” Effect Generates Even Bigger Returns than in the US The “turn-of-the-month” effect is one of the most fascinating stock market phenomena. It describes the fact that price gains primarily tend to occur around the turn of the month. By contrast, the rest of the time around the middle of the month is typically far less profitable for investors.   Good vs. bad seasonal timing...   [PT]   The effect has been studied...
  • Tales from “The Master of Disaster”
      Tightening Credit Markets Daylight extends a little further into the evening with each passing day.  Moods ease.  Contentment rises.  These are some of the many delights the northern hemisphere has to offer this time of year. As summer approaches, and dispositions loosen, something less amiable is happening.  Credit markets are tightening.  The yield on the 10-Year Treasury note has exceeded 3.12 percent.   A change in pace: yields are actually going somewhere. There is...
  • Is Political Decentralization the Only Hope for Western Civilization?
      Voting with their Feet A couple of recent articles have once more made the case, at least implicitly, for political decentralization as the only viable path which will begin to solve the seemingly insurmountable political, economic, and social crises which the Western world now faces.   Fracture lines – tax and regulatory competition allows people to “vote with their feet” - and they certainly do. [PT]   In the last few months, over 3,000 millionaires have...
  • Getting Out of Dodge
      Rare Commodity Modern economists are prone to shouting fire in a crowded theater.  The world is full of seeming incongruences. Economists puzzle over things like population growth and arable acres of farmland. They project out a linear scenario of increasing divergence, and see a catastrophe in the making.   Professional scaremonger Thomas Robert Malthus, one in a long line of scarcity prophets who failed to recognize the capacity of human ingenuity and free markets to...
  • “Sell In May And Go Away” - A Reminder: In 9 Out Of 11 Countries It Makes Sense To Do So
      A Truism that is Demonstrably True Most people are probably aware of the adage “sell in May and go away”. This popular seasonal Wall Street truism implies that the market's performance is far worse in the six summer months than in the six winter months. Numerous studies have been undertaken in this context particularly with respect to US stock markets, and they  confirm that the stock market on average exhibits relative weakness in the summer.   Look at the part we...
  • Why the Fundamental Gold Price Rose - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Gold Lending and Arbitrage There was no rise in the purchasing power of gold this week. The price of gold fell $22, and that of silver $0.19. One question that comes up is why is the fundamental price so far above the market price? Starting in January, the fundamental price began to move up sharply, and the move sustained through the end of April.   1-month LIBOR (London Interbank Offered Rate – the rate at which banks lend euro-dollars to each other). LIBOR and GOFO...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides


The Review Insider

Dog Blow

Austrian Theory and Investment



THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from]


Mish Talk

Buy Silver Now!
Buy Gold Now!

Diary of a Rogue Economist