Étatiste Crackpottery

Shortly after we posted Jayant Bhandari’s recent article that inter alia discussed  the new complex GST (general sales tax) regime introduced in India by the Modi government (see “The Lunatics Have Taken Over the Asylum” for details), we were contacted by Lakshminarayanan Kumaraapuram, a small businessman in Mumbai. He asked us whether we would be prepared to publish a comment he originally mailed to the prime minister’s “grievance portal”, so as to transform it into an open letter.


Let’s keep it simple… but not too simple. The chief surgeon gets ready to wield his scalpels and cleavers.


His comment underscores that small businessmen are indeed deeply unhappy about the new rules, and for good reason. As Jayant already mentioned, the effort one has to expend to comply with the new rules – which not even the bureaucrats who are tasked with enforcing them fully understand – is absolutely staggering (this includes having to file nearly 40 tax returns per year and being forced to ensure one’s suppliers’ compliance as well, with everyone being compelled to take on the role of unpaid tax collector).

We would note to this that the actions undertaken by the Modi government in recent months – beginning with the overnight demonetization of cash, to the introduction of a mandatory ID card, to the GST shenanigans – all remind us fatally of the interventionist measures many governments have eagerly implemented in nominally capitalist Western countries in recent years. The main difference is that India is even less suited to handle such impositions.

Whether or not this is intended, said measures all favor big, entrenched businesses to the detriment of individual entrepreneurs by essentially taxing and/or regulating small businesses out of existence. Financial privacy and economic freedom seem to be under attack from every conceivable angle almost everywhere. These ill-conceived stratagems, which appear to be based on the notion that citizens need to be placed under general suspicion and, to paraphrase Robert Nozick, that consenting adults have to be kept from engaging in voluntary capitalistic acts as much as possible, are supposedly inter alia aimed at boosting the tax revenues of assorted de facto bankrupt welfare states.

These brilliant ideas are cooked up by the same masterminds who believe we can actually get richer by debasing money, who are giving birth to Soviet-style “4 year plans”, are doing their best to roll back civilization in the name of “saving the planet” (demonstrating that their hubris knows no bounds) and  – considering various G20 communiques released in recent years – seem to have convinced themselves of the absurd fantasy that “economic growth” is something that is conjured into existence by government decree.

It is an apodictic certainty that whatever this bunch of economic illiterates comes up with (endorsed by their mediocre courtier economists though it may be) will not only fail to bring about the intended effects, but will end up doing the exact opposite. Experience suggest that once that happens, more, and in all likelihood worse, indignities will be inflicted on the tax serfs to “fix” the problem. Mr. Modi meanwhile seems intent on cementing his credentials as a trailblazer in étatiste crackpottery these days. IMF, World Bank and the largely execrable Western mainstream media seem duly impressed, while many of India’s poor are grinning and bearing it, presumably because they are used to being abused.


Indian bureaucrats groping the newest elephant in the darkroom.

Illustration via business-standard.com


Woe Is Us

Small businessmen in India seem less likely to succumb to passivity than the poor from what we could see so far, but they have so far been powerless to stop events from unfolding.

As Lakshminarayanan writes, right now he would be all for everybody going Galt:


“This is so silly an idea [the fact that about 40 tax returns are required every year for each province a company operates in] that even I am surprised it is part of GST. I have written to the PM’s Grievance Portal about this, but after a few days the status was “Thanks for your valuable feedback. Case closed.” […]

It is time for small businessmen to come together. Can small businessmen go on indefinite strike together? Close shop, whatever the losses. Let us see where the government goes for taxes.”


And here we go, with a poignant tale of woe…


Without further ado, here is what he sent to Mr. Modi’s “grievance portal” so that the intended recipient could proceed to ignore it with the alacrity of a power-drunk politician:


Woes of an Honest Tax-Paying Businessman due to GST

I am one of the probably millions of small businessmen who have been paying tax regularly over the last decade. I would like to highlight my woes and those of probably millions of other small businessmen due to the implementation of GST. While the hype generated by sloganeering that the corrupt will be caught may attract votes and win you elections, if your real purpose is to Make India Great Again [MIGA! ed.], then it is better done by implementing policies that make the lives of small businessmen simple and easy, so that they can focus on generating business and thereby provide employment instead of spending their money on filing returns.

From what I hear and understand, the only business that will flourish due to the  implementation of GST will be chartered accountants and the people who will gain employment due to GST will again only be chartered accountants. Even they will likely be hard pressed to get the people needed to man the job of filing returns. To get a measure of the problem please try and understand the plight of a businessman on the ground. Earlier, as a service tax payer, we would pay service tax every quarter and file returns twice a year. Also, we needed to file only one return every time. Now we are told that with the introduction of GST we will have to file returns every month, consisting of one return each for CGST, SGST and IGST  – which means we have to file 36 returns. Do you think it is right to burden small businessmen with such an onerous task?

Can you imagine how heavily this is going to weigh on small businesses? Also, can you truthfully say that it is a progressive step to make businessmen spend more time, effort and money on filing returns when the same time, effort and money could be used to increase business and create employment? I would also like you to look at the aspect of implementation. Can you imagine how difficult it is going to be to keep track of whether millions of businesses have filed their returns and taken action month after month (despite the power of computers)? To put this in perspective, suppose that ten percent of  all companies are not able to do this month after month, which means lakhs of businesses every month, which will inevitably become millions and crores in a few years.*

Don’t you think that this task will soon become too daunting? Now to go after that many companies, you are going to need a horde of enforcement officers. Thus, in the long run, the mandatory filing of returns every month will ensure that there will eventually be more enforcement officers and chartered accountants than businesses. It is highly regrettable that a Government that prides itself on focusing on creating jobs and improving the ease of doing business can take a step that is by its very nature regressive, as it wastes resources and does not add to the economy.

Therefore it is my earnest request that you look into this and ensure that life is made as easy as possible for the small businessman (who, by the way, is beset with umpteen problems without the need for government to foist even more on him) and ensure that he is able to focus on his business and contribute to the economy.

Regards, Lakshminarayanan


* Note: 1 lakh = 100,000, 1 crore = 10,000,000


Be Careful What You Wish For

Our correspondent from Mumbai is hopeful that at least the faces of those in charge will eventually change again. As he tells us:


The present Modi government is on a high because it keeps winning elections. Since poor people outnumber educated and rich people in the country, rhetorics and theatrics (Modi is a great orator) are doing the job of garnering votes right now and he appears invincible. But then, it was like this when Indira Gandhi was powerful too. Since each dog has its day, I am sure the day will come when the opposition will emerge stronger again.”


Now, we can understand that many businessmen are unhappy with Mr. Modi and his his recent policy initiatives, and admittedly, we are thoroughly ignorant of the policies espoused by the modern-day version of the Congress Party. But this may be a case of “be careful what you wish for”. Indira Ghandi was a prime example of the  slightly unhealthy predilection for “strong leaders” Indian voters appear to harbor.

She inter alia presided over a state of emergency, during which civil liberties were suspended, she ruled by decree and opposition politicians were jailed… she  waged war both within India and against neighboring countries, she was convicted of electoral fraud by the Supreme Court (a verdict she simply ignored), and she nationalized the banking, oil, coal, steel, copper, refining, textile and insurance industries, while putting what remained of the private sector into a corset of stringent regulations. She was also known for fostering nepotism and implemented socialistic “5 year plans”, which mirabile dictu, were exceeded every time!

The Indian Libertarian wrote about Indira Ghandi in 1969, six years before the state of emergency was declared:


“It would be difficult to find a more machiavellian leftist than Mrs. Indira Gandhi… for here is Machiavelli at his best, in the person of a suave, charming and astute politician.”


As Jayant Bhandari has already occasionally warned in his usually less than cheerful missives, whoever comes after Modi may easily turn out to be even worse. Then again, failed economic policies sooner or later always provoke corrective action, often because there is no other choice.


Sometimes one jumps out of the fire only to land in the frying pan…

Cartoon by Gary Larson




Emigrate While You Can... Learn More




Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.


Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA


One Response to “India’s GST: A Small Businessman Speaks Out”

  • Kafka:

    Ah, yes, the GST, a “value-added” tax. Touted as more fair, easier to administer, etc. But it doesn’t replace any other tax, so it is just another tax upon all the other taxes government foists upon small business to collect.

    My observation is the parasites outnumber producers. And the parasites are growing in number as producers shrink.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • US Stock Market: Conspicuous Similarities with 1929, 1987 and Japan in 1990
      Stretched to the Limit There are good reasons to suspect that the bull market in US equities has been stretched to the limit. These include inter alia: high fundamental valuation levels, as e.g. illustrated by the Shiller P/E ratio (a.k.a. “CAPE”/ cyclically adjusted P/E); rising interest rates; and the maturity of the advance.   The end of an era - a little review of the mother of modern crash patterns, the 1929 debacle. In hindsight it is both a bit scary and sad, in...
  • A Giant Ouija Board - Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      Object of Speculation The prices of the metals fell last week, $22 and $0.24 respectively. It’s an odd thing, isn’t it? Each group of traders knows how gold “should” react to a particular type of news. But they all want the same thing — they want gold to go up. And when it doesn’t, many hesitate to buy. Or even sell. This is why speculation cannot set a stable price (I’m talking to you, bitcoiners).   Everybody wants gold to grow wings. Unfortunately it's rather...
  • How to Blow $12.2 Billion in No Time Flat
      Fake Responses  One month ago we asked: What kind of stock market purge is this?  Over the last 30 days the stock market’s offered plenty of fake responses.  Yet we’re still waiting for a clear answer.   As the party continues, the dance moves of the revelers are becoming ever more ominous. Are they still right in the head? Perhaps a little trepanation is called for to relieve those brain tensions a bit?  [PT]   The stock market, like the President,...
  • Purchasing Power Parity or Nominal Exchange Rates?
      Extracting Meaning from PPP   “An alternative exchange rate - the purchasing power parity (PPP) conversion factor - is preferred because it reflects differences in price levels for both tradable and non-tradable goods and services and therefore provides a more meaningful comparison of real output.” – the World Bank   Headquarters of the World Bank in Washington. We have it on good authority that the business of ending poverty is quite lucrative for its practitioners...
  • Broken Promises
      Demanding More Debt Consumer debt, corporate debt, and government debt are all going up.  But that’s not all.  Margin debt – debt that investors borrow against their portfolio to buy more stocks – has hit a record of $642.8 billion.  What in the world are people thinking?   A blow-off in margin debt mirroring the blow-off in stock prices. Since February of 2016 alone it has soared by ~$170 billion - this is an entirely new level insanity. The current total of 643...
  • Stock and Bond Markets - The Augustine of Hippo Plea
      Lord, Grant us Chastity and Temperance... Just Not Yet! Most fund managers are in an unenviable situation nowadays (particularly if they have a long only mandate). On the one hand, they would love to get an opportunity to buy assets at reasonable prices. On the other hand, should asset prices actually return to levels that could be remotely termed “reasonable”, they would be saddled with staggering losses from their existing exposure. Or more precisely: their investors would be saddled...
  • Despondency in Silver-Land
      Speculators Throw the Towel Over the past several years we have seen a few amazing moves in futures positioning in a number of commodities, such as e.g. in crude oil, where the by far largest speculative long positions in history have been amassed. Over the past year it was silver's turn. In April 2017, large speculators had built up a record net long position of more than 103,000 contracts in silver futures with the metal trading at $18.30. At the end of February of this year, they held...
  • From Bling to Plonk – An Update on the Debt Mountain
      Serenely Grows the Debtberg We mentioned in a recent post that we would soon return to the topic of credit spreads and exotic structured products. One reason for doing so are the many surprises investors faced in the 2008 crisis. Readers may e.g. remember auction rate securities. These bonds were often listed as “cash equivalents” on the balance sheets of assorted companies investing in them, but it turned out they were anything but. Shareholders of many small and mid-sized companies...
  • US Equities – Mixed Signals Battling it Out
      A Warning Signal from Market Internals Readers may recall that we looked at various market internals after the sudden sell-offs in August 2015 and January 2016 in order to find out if any of them had provided clear  advance warning. One that did so was the SPX new highs/new lows percent index (HLP). Below is the latest update of this indicator.   HLP (uppermost panel) provided advance warning prior to the sell-offs of August 2015 and January 2016 by dipping noticeably below the...
  • Return of the Market Criers - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Ballistically Yours One nearly-famous gold salesman blasted subscribers this week with, “Gold Is Going to Go Ballistic!” A numerologist shouted out the number $10,000. At the county fair this weekend, we ran out of pocket change, so we did not have a chance to see the Tarot Card reader to get a confirmation. The market criers are back in gold town [PT]   Even if you think that the price of gold is going to go a lot higher (which we do, by the way—but to lean on...
  • Good Riddance Lloyd Blankfein!
      One and the Same   “God gave me my money.” – John D. Rockefeller   Today we step away from the economy and markets and endeavor down the path less traveled.  For fun and for free, we wade out into a smelly peat bog.  There we scratch away the surface muck in search of what lies below.   One should actually be careful about quotes like the one attributed to Rockefeller above, even if it of course sounds good and is very suitable for the topic at...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides


Austrian Theory and Investment



THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts


Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]



USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]


Buy Silver Now!
Buy Gold Now!


Diary of a Rogue Economist