Endangered Recovery

As we noted in a recent corporate debt update on occasion of the troubles Neiman-Marcus finds itself in (see “Cracks in Ponzi Finance Land”), problems are set to emerge among high-yield borrowers in the US retail sector this year. This happens just as similar problems among low-rated borrowers in the oil sector were mitigated by the rally in oil prices since early 2016. The recovery in the oil sector seems increasingly endangered though.

 

Too many oil barrels are filling up again.

Photo credit: Kay Nietfeld / DPA / Corbis

 

Here is a chart we have frequently shown in the past, which illustrates the y/y change rate in commercial & industrial loan charge-offs plus delinquencies in comparison to junk bond yields (the federal funds rate is added for good measure):

 

Year-on-year rate of change in charge-offs + delinquencies of C&I loans (black, lhs) vs. junk bond yields (blue, rhs) and the FF rate (red, rhs) – click to enlarge.

 

To avoid misinterpretations of this chart, note that the big surge in the rate of change of charge-offs/delinquencies obviously started from very low levels. In absolute terms it came nowhere near to the levels that were seen in 2008 – 2009. Both the increase in charge-offs and delinquencies and the improvement over recent quarters closely tracked the problems and subsequent recovery in the oil & gas sector as the oil price plunged from late 2014 to early 2016 and then rebounded.

Whether the expected surge in retail sector defaults this year will have an impact on this statistic remains to be seen of course. The surge in junk bond yields from the 2014 lows to the early 2016 highs and the subsequent decline close to previous lows were likewise largely related to the energy sector, which is home to a great many junk-rated borrowers.

They happen to borrow quite tidy sums as well, so these developments are not inconsequential from a wider economic perspective. In recent years US capital spending growth and data reported by the manufacturing sector (especially by producers of capital goods) appeared to be quite closely correlated with the fate of the oil sector as well, or more precisely, the fate of the fracking industry.

All of this must be brought into context with monetary policy. Large increases in the money supply and the associated decrease in interest rates tend to drive up prices of factors in the higher stages of the production structure, i.e., those that are temporally distant from the consumer goods stage. As an aside to this, readers may wonder why the retail industry is facing problems if that is so – to this one has to keep in mind that over-consumption is a feature of the boom as well, as is the fact that investment is derailed into the wrong lines. These are the factors affecting the retail sector.

The main “beneficiaries” of the boom are always specific sectors of the economy, which absorb a particularly large share of investment financed by newly created money and credit. Which sectors precisely depends on contingent circumstances (e.g. the fracking industry benefited from the perception that China would boost global oil demand and from technological advances that made fracking viable).

In hindsight we can state that the oil industry’s problems did not suffice to derail the slow-motion economic recovery, as money supply growth remained strong and other sectors took up the slack. However, as we have pointed out on several occasions in recent weeks, money and credit growth are now faltering (See “The Triumph of Hope over Experience” for recent money supply charts).

 

Light sweet crude oil, daily, over the past two years. Recently prices have declined well below both the 50 and 200 day moving average, for the first time since moving above them in 2016 (see the bluish rectangle). Crude oil is now approaching an initial range of lateral support. Should it fail to halt the decline, the next support range awaits between roughly $38 to $40. Below ~$40 a large amount of shale production is reportedly not viable, despite ongoing advances in extraction technology – click to enlarge.

 

As the chart above indicates, the recovery in the oil sector could soon be in jeopardy. Oil prices have declined noticeably in recent weeks, and even though major support levels haven’t been breached yet, the decline is more concerning from a technical perspective than previous corrections were, due to the movement of prices relative to important moving averages. There is more to this though, as the market structure gives cause for concern as well (more on this further below).

 

Self-Defeating Enthusiasm

As we were pondering likely developments in the sector, we came across a tweet by Ian Shepherdson from the end of April on an interesting detail in the Q1 GDP report. Here it is:

 

Oil drillers are getting busy

 

Given the previous sharp decline in the rig count, this surge in investment into new oil wells comes off very low levels as well of course, so it is probably not as impressive in absolute terms. What it illustrates though is that any rally in the oil price very quickly leads to sizable increases in the production of shale oil. This is not surprising, as the troubled debtors in the sector still have to produce as much as they can to keep servicing their debt.

This holds also for companies that have successfully restructured their debt in the past year or so – if one looks at the details of these restructuring efforts, many have only provided a very limited increase in flexibility, and usually at great cost. The extremely fast decline rates of shale production wells play into this as well of course, but that can hardly be seen as a positive factor, even if it is putting a small brake on the overall surge in supply.

In chart form the Q1 surge in investment in oil drilling looks quite daunting – it can probably be seen as a symptom of the self-defeating nature of this cycle, since it lowers the probability that current oil prices will be maintained or that an even bigger rally will emerge. To be sure, all of that could change dramatically once the trend in monetary policy turns toward loosening rather than tightening again.

As we have often pointed out, one must always keep monetary factors in mind when analyzing commodity prices. Supply and demand related to commodities themselves are very important, but they are not everything. Any material change in market perceptions regarding the future purchasing power of money will affect their prices as well – but such changes in “price inflation” expectations may do little to improve the margins of producers, as their input costs are liable to increase just as fast in that case (leads and lags may create a temporarily favorable situation, but if so, it won’t last long).

 

Quarterly annualized real investment in mining structures (most of which is oil-related investment). Low base or not, Q1 2017 is quite the stand-out – click to enlarge.

 

Even coming off a low base, the increase in spending on oil drilling in Q1 is astonishing. The relatively strong showing of manufacturing PMIs in recent months was very likely influenced by this as well. That brings us to another part of the oil market in which way too much enthusiasm is in evidence.

 

Ominous Market Structure

Back in 2014 we kept wondering about the huge surge in net speculative long positions in WTIC futures. We considered the possibility that they may partly have reflected arbitrage intended to capture movements in the spread between WTIC and Brent, but we couldn’t find any really convincing evidence for this. Generally there has been an explosion in speculative positioning records across all tradable instruments in the post-GFC era, which we ultimately attribute to the unremitting flood of central bank-created liquidity (this is also affecting trends in CLO and leveraged loan markets, which we will take a look at next).

For much of 2014 the large net long position held by speculators seemed not to matter, as crude oil prices remained firm. But it turned out that the latent threat such a position represents was very real once the trend changed and prices violated important technical levels. The recent situation is not merely just as bad, it is actually worse. Below is a long term chart of the net hedger position (the inverse of the combined speculative position) illustrating the succession of extreme readings since 2008.

 

Net position of hedgers in WTIC futures (the inverse of the net speculative position).  Once upon a time, a net position of 100k-150k contracts was considered huge and a sign that caution was warranted. These records have long been left in the dust. Note that even after the recent reduction in the net position, we are currently not far from the most extreme levels of 2014, shortly before the market tanked. The red vertical lines are aligned with price highs in crude oil. Often the size of the net position will decrease shortly before prices peak. This was very much evident in 2008 when oil entered the blow-off stage of the bull market. It actually succeeded in mowing down at least one large commercial hedger, as the company was no longer able to service its margin calls (it had off-setting inventory, but margin calls require one to put up cash immediately, and getting hold of cash in 2008 was at times difficult). At the 2014 secondary peak just before the market slumped, the net position and prices peaked at the same time though – click to enlarge.

 

One thing that stands out to us in the context of the rebound since early 2016, is that a lot of speculative “firepower” was expended in what is actually a rather middling price rally with very little momentum apart from its initial phase. Between November 2016 and February 2017 the speculative position more than doubled, with speculators adding nearly 300,000 contracts net, which resulted in moving prices from around $47/ bbl. to $54/bbl. Although this big commitment of money has not exacty produced a gain worth writing home about, the huge net position now hangs over the market like the sword of Damocles.

 

The Damocles situation

Painting by Richard Westall

 

Conclusion

It is of course possible that the market will prove resilient for a while and remain in a trading range a little longer, similar to the situation in much of 2014. We would be concerned though given the slowdown in money supply and credit growth that important support levels will eventually be breached. Once that happens, there can be little doubt that much of the large speculative position will be liquidated and prices will cascade lower just as they did in 2014. In that case one would have to bid adieu to the brief period of relief in this sector of junk-bond land as well.

If – as seems likely – other sectors get into trouble concurrently, a broader change in perceptions will take hold. For instance, worries about the supply of corporate debt being “too small” have been frequently voiced of late (no kidding!), as speculation in all sorts of structured products and junk bonds heats up and spreads are compressed to unheard of levels. We suspect such worries are bound to evaporate in a flash, along with the recent surfeit in liquidity. Stay tuned, more on this topic is coming soon.

 

Charts by: St. Louis Fed, stockcharts.com, Ian Shepherdson, sentimentrader

 

 
 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

   
 

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Can Germany Be Made Great Again?
      When Germany Was Great! Ever since the start of the deliberately conceived “migrant crisis,” orchestrated by NWO elites, the news out of Germany has been, to say the least, horrific. Right before the eyes of the world, a country is being demographically destroyed through a coercive plan of mass migration.  The intended consequences of this – financial strain, widespread crime and property destruction, the breakdown of German culture – will continue to worsen if things are not...
  • Yanking the Bank of Japan’s Chain
      Mathematical Certainties Based on the simple reflection that arithmetic is more than just an abstraction, we offer a modest observation.  The social safety nets of industrialized economies, including the United States, have frayed at the edges.  Soon the safety net’s fabric will snap. This recognition is not an opinion.  Rather, it’s a matter of basic arithmetic.  The economy cannot sustain the government obligations that have been piled up upon it over the last 70...
  • Views From the Top of the Skyscraper Index
      Views From the Top of the Skyscraper Index On a warm Friday Los Angeles morning in spring of 2016, we found ourselves standing at the busy corner of Wilshire Boulevard and South Figueroa Street.  We were walking back to our office following a client wire brushing for events beyond our control.  But we had other thoughts on our mind.   Iron workers (the non-distraught variety) atop the 10 ton spire of the Wilshire Grand Center in Lost Angeles. This image is vaguely...
  • Prepare for Another Market Face Pounding
      “Better than Goldilocks” “Markets make opinions,” goes the old Wall Street adage.  Indeed, this sounds like a nifty thing to say.  But what does it really mean?   The bears discover Mrs. Locks in their bed and it seems they are less than happy. [PT]   Perhaps this means that after a long period of rising stocks prices otherwise intelligent people conceive of clever explanations for why the good times will carry on.  Moreover, if the market goes up for...
  • Bitcoin, Gold and Silver
      Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report That’s it. It’s the final straw. One of the alternative investing newsletters had a headline that screamed, “Bitcoin Is About to Soar, But You Must Act by August 1 to Get In". It was missing only the call to action “call 1-800-BIT-COIN now! That number again is 800 B.I.T..C.O.I.N.”   Bitcoin, daily. In terms of the gains recorded between the lows of 2009 and the recent highs (from less eight hundredths of a US cent per...
  • Seasonality: Will Patterns that Worked in the Past Also Work in the Future?
      Historians of the Future Every investor makes trading decisions based on what happened in the past – there is no other way. What really interests us is the future though. After all, what happens in the future ultimately determines investment success.   When in doubt, you can always try to reach the pasture...  In Human Action, Ludwig von Mises described stock market speculators as akin to “historians of the future”. This is without a doubt the most trenchant definition of...
  • Bitcoin Forked – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      A Fork in the Cryptographic Road So bitcoin forked. You did not know this. Well, if you’re saving in gold perhaps not. If you’re betting in the crypto-coin casino, you knew it, bet on it, and now we assume are happily diving into your greater quantity of dollars after the fork.   Bitcoin, daily – adding the current price of BCH (the new type of Bitcoin all holders of BTC can claim at a 1:1 ratio), the gain since the “fork” amounts to roughly $1,000 at the time we...
  • What Went Wrong With the 21st Century?
      Fools and Rascals   And it’s time, time, time And it’s time, time, time It’s time, time, time that you love And it’s time, time, time… - Tom  Waits   Tom Waits rasps about time   POITOU, FRANCE – “So how much did you make last night?” “We made about $15,000,” came the reply from our eldest son, a keen cryptocurrency investor. “Bitcoin briefly pierced the $3,500 mark – an all-time high. The market cap of the...
  • Czar vs. Pope
      Vladimir the Great Sums Up Pope Francis the Fake Vladimir Putin has once again demonstrated why he is the most perceptive, farsighted, and for a politician, the most honest world leader to come around in quite a while.  If it had not been for his patient and wise statesmanship, the world may have already been embroiled in an all-encompassing global conflagration with the possibility of thermonuclear destruction.   Vladimir Putin is sizing up Pope Francis with his “good...
  • Bitcoin Has No Yield, but Gold Does – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      Bitcoin and Credit Transactions Last week, we said:   It is commonly accepted to say the dollar is “printed”, but we can see from this line of thinking it is really borrowed. There is a real borrower on the other side of the transaction, and that borrower has powerful motivations to keep paying to service the debt. Bitcoin has no backing. Bitcoin is created out of thin air, the way people say of the dollar. The quantity of bitcoins created may be strictly limited by...
  • Is Historically Low Volatility About to Expand?
      Suspicion Asleep You have probably noticed it already: stock market volatility has recently all but disappeared. This raises an important question for every investor: Has the market established a permanent plateau of low volatility, or is the current period of low volatility just the calm before the storm?   All quiet on the VIX front... what can possibly happen? [PT] - click to enlarge.   When such questions regarding future market trends arise, it is often...
  • Will They Haul Off Trump’s Statue, Too?
      Confused by Shadows POITOU, FRANCE – This week, we are talking about theperishable nature of gods. Yesterday, the city fathers of our hometown of Baltimore let it be known that it was time to toss out the old deities.   The Robert E. Lee and Thomas. J. “Stonewall” Jackson Monument in Baltimore, which the mayor inter alia wants to remove. Suddenly it has become fashionable to erase the memory of an important part of US history all over the country. By experience, this...

Support Acting Man

j9TJzzN

Austrian Theory and Investment

Own physical gold and silver outside a bank

Archive

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com