Hidden Motives

It is well-known that India’s government wants to coerce its population into “modernizing” its financial behavior and abandoning its traditions. The recent ban on large-denomination banknotes was not only meant to fight corruption.

 

very-bad-boyObviously, this very bad Indian has way too much cash. Just look at him, he looks suspicious!

Photo via thenewsminute.com

 

In fact, as our friend Jayant Bhandari has pointed out, fresh avenues for corruption  immediately opened up upon enactment of the ban (see “Gold Price Skyrockets in India After Currency Ban” – Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3).

It is a nigh apodictic certainty that governments are lying – whether outright or by omission – when they impose such drastic measures. It should be clear how the State operates once one recognizes its true nature and realizes that “we” are definitely not the State.

Thus there are several reasons for the currency ban that have nothing to do with the official justification forwarded by the government. One is of course that the government hopes to be able to confiscate a sizable proportion of the citizenry’s  – allegedly “ill-gotten” – wealth.

A special one-off tax penalty will be imposed on deposits government officials arbitrarily deem “too large” – under the cover that only criminals will be deprived of their possessions, for the benefit of public at large (meaning: Modi’s supporters. As an aside, this may well turn out to be a major miscalculation).

Another reason is that the government wants to coerce people into transferring much of the cash they currently hold into the banking system. This will transform their cash into digital money substitutes.

This increase in deposit money will be a great boon for India’s fractionally reserved banks. It represents extremely cheap funding for them and will enable them to vastly expand credit creation ex nihilo. At the same time, the government will achieve far greater control over the economic life of its citizens.

 

Indians and Gold- A Rational Love Affair

In the recent past, India’s government has also launched several initiatives aimed at reducing gold purchases by Indian citizens. For one thing, it is asserted that the gold hoards held by citizens are “unproductive” and a sign of India’s backwardness that needs to be eradicated in the name of modernization.

Another  official reason is that government wants to lower the country’s trade deficit. Since India isn’t producing much gold, it is importing quite a lot; in recent years gold imports oscillated around 700 tons per year.

 

1-india-balance-of-trade3xIndia’s trade deficit over the past decade – cick to enlarge.

 

The world’s governments are almost without exception comprised of  economically ignorant mercantilists who believe that a trade deficit is a symptom of declining wealth. Naturally, India’s government is no different in this respect.

This mercantilist view of trade is one of the most “sticky” and widespread economic errors in history (evidently, not only prices and wages are “sticky”…). It is a direct result of viewing the economy through a collectivist lens instead of through the lens of methodological individualism.

The government’s efforts included raising a tariff on gold imports (ever since, India’s gold import statistics are no longer reliable, as a lot of gold is smuggled in), as well as urging the creation of assorted “paper gold” products by commercial banks.

The latter were supposed to entice citizens to deposit their gold with banks in exchange for paper receipts. You have one guess why the government would be eager to see that happen.

India’s citizens have a traditional affinity for gold. Gold is not only a “love trade”  for Indians though, as our friend Ronnie Stoeferle puts it. They also buy gold because they don’t trust their government and its economic policies.

 

gold-jewellery-reLooking good, ma’am.

Photo credit: Reuters

 

As has just been demonstrated again, this is quite a healthy attitude – even if the  government of the day is widely considered to be “good for the economy” (Mr. Modi’s government has indeed adopted a number of positive economic reforms as well in the past).

Not only can it be very costly to trust the government, there is obviously also a big difference between looking at and fondling actual metal, as opposed to a bank receipt for a gold deposit. If you try it, you will see it is just not the same.

Indian women love gold adornments and gold jewelry plays a major role as a wedding present that concurrently serves as a store of wealth. Hence the government’s efforts to “wean the citizenry off gold” have completely failed to gain traction.

 

What If India Bans Gold Imports?

It remains to be seen if the government will get away unscathed with the recent demonetization of large denomination banknotes. As Jayant has pointed out, Mr. Modi has actually enjoyed widespread popular support for the measure – at least initially. Certain segments of society continue to be supportive, depending on the degree to which they are actually affected by the ban.

 

money-atms_825_ptiThe degree of Modi’s support is presumably inversely proportional to the length of time spent in such queues.

Photo via twitter.com

 

After two weeks of increasing chaos and ample demonstrations of government ineptitude, the political opposition has finally decided to join the fray and is now beginning to forcefully denounce the measure.

Parliament was adjourned after an “uproar” over the currency ban,  the opposition is organizing an “all India protest” for November 28, as it is now united in opposing the ban.  Moreover, allegations that the plan was leaked to certain people in advance have surfaced (that wouldn’t surprise us one bit).

As Jayant has rightly pointed out in the third part of his articles on the currency ban, the evolving situation is forcing the government to continually issue new ad hoc decrees in order to stop people from successfully fighting the edict.

Similar to the attempts of the post-revolutionary assembly of France to defend the assignat in the late 18th century, it is resorting to increasingly repressive steps (the most recent one is that it has apparently suddenly shortened the grace period for banknote exchanges, concurrently with announcing that it will impose a  tax penalty on “too large” deposits).

This has led to speculation that gold may be in the government’s cross hairs next.  As the thinking goes, if it can ban certain banknotes, surely it can also enact a ban on gold imports? As an aside, an outright ban on gold ownership seems highly unlikely, as that would probably cause more than just an “uproar”.

 

kalyan_jewellers_2367472gBanning gold ownership is out of the question.

Photo credit: Kalyan jewellers

 

Also, some of the largest gold hoards are held by temples – in other words, the country’s religious establishment would undoubtedly be less than amused. Gold imports are a different matter though.

A recent article posted at Zerohedge discusses the possibility and attempts to estimate what the potential impact on gold prices might be. First let us consider the question whether the recent decline in gold prices may have had anything to do with rumors about India imposing a ban on gold imports. We would argue this is extremely unlikely.

First of all, at the recent peak in gold prices, the net speculative position in gold futures had reached a record high. Even though one needs to interpret the commitments of traders in gold futures in a more nuanced manner than many observers are wont to do, we have pointed out on several occasions that this made the market very vulnerable to a shake-out. The only question was when it would start and how extensive it would be.

 

2-net-spec-positionNet and gross positions of speculators in COMEX gold futures – note that these data refer to the CoT report of November 15, which in turn is a snapshot of the actual situation as of November 12. Due to the holiday schedule, new data will only become available on Monday.  As of November 12, the total net speculative position had declined from a 340,000 contract peak in early July to less than 200,000 contracts – it has probably decreased further in the meantime – click to enlarge.

 

The correction has in fact turned out to be a lot more extensive than we thought it would be, partly driven by the market reaction to the Republican clean sweep of the election. At least we didn’t neglect to mention that the large speculative position was likely to “require more work” (this has probably been achieved by now).

The proximate driver of the decline in gold prices was the surge in the US dollar, which in turn appears to have been egged on by rising bond yields – particularly a reversal in real interest rates as reflected by TIPS yields. These have in the meantime reached positive territory again, if only by a few basis points. It is the trend that counts though, and perceptions about the future trend.

 

3-dxyDXY daily – relative to this move, gold has held up quite well actually – click to enlarge.

 

4-five-year-tips-yield5 year TIPS yield: real US interest rates were in negative for most of 2016, but have now returned above the zero line – if barely – click to enlarge.

 

Fundamental Drivers of the Gold Price

In the above mentioned article it is also emphasized that a gold import ban by India is likely provoke a “$200 one day crash” in gold prices. We don’t know how this estimate was arrived at.

We concede that such news would likely have a negative effect on market psychology, but we cannot really estimate its size. We only know that in the long term it would merely amount to short term variance.

Many market participants and observers continue to be blissfully unaware of how to properly analyze the gold market and continue to look at gold supply and demand as though the metal were an industrial commodity.

This is not the case though – in reality, the markets treat gold as though it were money (even though it currently does not serve as an official medium of exchange), and it is in fact the world’s fourth-most liquid currency in terms of  average daily trading volume.

 

5-lbma-turnoverLBMA turnover, Q1 2011 annualized. Note that this does not only represent physical trades, and certain transactions are actually not included. We will discuss these figures in more detail on another occasion – the point here is merely to show that an enormous amount of gold is traded every day – click to enlarge.

 

India imports 700 tons of gold per year – but in London alone, nearly 600 tons are changing hands every single trading day. Quite a bit of gold is already smuggled into India in order to sidestep the import surcharge. An import  ban would no doubt intensify these smuggling activities and gold would continue to enter India below the authorities’ radar.

This not really important though – one has to consider the true supply-demand situation when analyzing gold.  Since gold is not “used up”,  nearly every single ounce ever mined continues to be part of the global supply.

It is precisely because gold has such a huge ratio of stocks to flows that it is useful as a money commodity. At a minimum, the total supply consists of 180,000 tons, and very likely it is actually greater (around 3,000 tons, or 1.4%, are added to the total supply every year by mine production).

Let us assume that the 180,000 tons figure is correct. Obviously, this means that the total demand for gold (including reservation demand) is also 180,000 tons, since supply and demand have to be equal. India’s annual imports therefore amount to about 0.39% of the world’s total gold supply and demand, which is basically a rounding error.

 

6-cnimportsvssgeGold imports to China and withdrawals from the Shanghai Gold Exchange. This shows that there is growing interest in gold by Chinese buyers, which is of course positive in principle. But it cannot alter what the major forces driving prices consist of – click to enlarge.

 

Readers may recall the many stories about surging Chinese gold imports, which regularly made the rounds while the gold price fell by nearly 46% between late 2011 and late 2015. The vast majority of these reports implied that surging Chinese imports should lead to rising prices, but the exact opposite has in fact happened.

It should be clear that prices don’t rise just because gold is moved from A to B After all, someone had to sell and export what Chinese buyers bought and imported. Prices merely reflect the relative urgency with which buyers and sellers act.

Also, while the amounts involved looked quite large relative to e.g. the WGC’s supply-demand statistics – which analyze only the estimated annual flow of gold, and completely ignore the much larger stock – they were really tiny compared to total global gold supply and demand. India’s annual imports are even smaller.

 

Conclusion

Readers who have not yet seen the articles on the topic of gold market analysis which have preciously appeared in these pages, are advised to review the following:

Misconceptions About Gold (by yours truly)

What Determines the Price of Gold?  (an excellent article by Robert Bumen that inter alia discusses the concept of reservation demand in detail).

The upshot of all this is that for psychological reasons it is reasonable to expect a short term negative reaction if India were to ban gold imports, but the trend will continue to be determined by the true fundamental drivers of the gold price. How many tons of gold are moved from one place of the world to another in the course of a year is not really relevant in this context.

Gold demand is driven by macroeconomic factors, some of which are overlapping. They include:

 

  • market-derived real interest rates,
  • the trend of the US dollar,
  • credit spreads,
  • the steepness of the yield curve,
  • faith in the monetary authorities,
  • faith in the solvency of the banking system,
  • faith in government and particularly its fiscal policy,
  • money supply growth rates,
  • the general trend in commodity prices,
  • the trend in risk asset prices,
  • the demand for money (i.e., the desire to increase precautionary cash balances), the trend in economic confidence in general

 

What can be safely excluded  – apart from short term psychological considerations –  are things like mine supply, scrap supply, imports to certain countries, the amount of gold held by bullion ETFs (which is a useful sentiment indicator though) and similar exercises involving the addition and subtraction to and from annual gold flows.

These marginal changes may exacerbate or mitigate short term price trends, but they can never be the major determinants of the gold price.

 

stacking-goldUnknown stacker at work. A lot of gold is in fact not available anywhere near current prices, as its owners have very high reservation demand.

Photo via thehindu.com

 

Charts by: TradingEconomics, StockCharts, St. Louis Federal Reserve Research, ShareLynx.

 

 
 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

   
 

One Response to “A Note on Gold and India – What is Driving the Gold Price?”

  • rowingboat:

    “Prices merely reflect the relative urgency with which buyers and sellers act.”
    “India imports 700 tons of gold per year”

    By examining the trade data of major gold centres (Switzerland, USA, HK, China, India, Canada etc) this urgency is most expressed by flows into and out of the UK.

    In the case of an import ban in India, what’s the worst that could happen? A negative delta of 700mt (in reality the change would be much less as smuggling would increase and presumably very significantly depending on the premium).

    Now look at the UK:

    2006-12: 600mt annual IMport, average.
    2013-15: 800mt annual EXport, average).
    2016: 1100mt IMport YTD (to September).

    The UK negative delta from bull market to bear (2013-15) and positive delta 2015 to 2016 simply overwhelm changes that we observe elsewhere. When November’s trade data is available we will see significant gold flowing from the UK again, a dramatic shift from what has formerly occurred in 2016.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Yanking the Bank of Japan’s Chain
      Mathematical Certainties Based on the simple reflection that arithmetic is more than just an abstraction, we offer a modest observation.  The social safety nets of industrialized economies, including the United States, have frayed at the edges.  Soon the safety net’s fabric will snap. This recognition is not an opinion.  Rather, it’s a matter of basic arithmetic.  The economy cannot sustain the government obligations that have been piled up upon it over the last 70...
  • Prepare for Another Market Face Pounding
      “Better than Goldilocks” “Markets make opinions,” goes the old Wall Street adage.  Indeed, this sounds like a nifty thing to say.  But what does it really mean?   The bears discover Mrs. Locks in their bed and it seems they are less than happy. [PT]   Perhaps this means that after a long period of rising stocks prices otherwise intelligent people conceive of clever explanations for why the good times will carry on.  Moreover, if the market goes up for...
  • The Future of the Third World
      Decolonization The British Empire was the largest in history. At the end of World War II Britain had to start pulling out from its colonies. A major part of the reason was, ironically, the economic prosperity that had come through industrialization, massive improvements in transportation, and the advent of telecommunications, ethnic and religious respect, freedom of speech, and other liberties offered by the empire.   The colors represent the colonies of various nations...
  • What Went Wrong With the 21st Century?
      Fools and Rascals   And it’s time, time, time And it’s time, time, time It’s time, time, time that you love And it’s time, time, time… - Tom  Waits   Tom Waits rasps about time   POITOU, FRANCE – “So how much did you make last night?” “We made about $15,000,” came the reply from our eldest son, a keen cryptocurrency investor. “Bitcoin briefly pierced the $3,500 mark – an all-time high. The market cap of the...
  • Bitcoin Forked – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      A Fork in the Cryptographic Road So bitcoin forked. You did not know this. Well, if you’re saving in gold perhaps not. If you’re betting in the crypto-coin casino, you knew it, bet on it, and now we assume are happily diving into your greater quantity of dollars after the fork.   Bitcoin, daily – adding the current price of BCH (the new type of Bitcoin all holders of BTC can claim at a 1:1 ratio), the gain since the “fork” amounts to roughly $1,000 at the time we...
  • Czar vs. Pope
      Vladimir the Great Sums Up Pope Francis the Fake Vladimir Putin has once again demonstrated why he is the most perceptive, farsighted, and for a politician, the most honest world leader to come around in quite a while.  If it had not been for his patient and wise statesmanship, the world may have already been embroiled in an all-encompassing global conflagration with the possibility of thermonuclear destruction.   Vladimir Putin is sizing up Pope Francis with his “good...
  • Seasonality: Will Patterns that Worked in the Past Also Work in the Future?
      Historians of the Future Every investor makes trading decisions based on what happened in the past – there is no other way. What really interests us is the future though. After all, what happens in the future ultimately determines investment success.   When in doubt, you can always try to reach the pasture...  In Human Action, Ludwig von Mises described stock market speculators as akin to “historians of the future”. This is without a doubt the most trenchant definition of...
  • Bitcoin Has No Yield, but Gold Does – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      Bitcoin and Credit Transactions Last week, we said:   It is commonly accepted to say the dollar is “printed”, but we can see from this line of thinking it is really borrowed. There is a real borrower on the other side of the transaction, and that borrower has powerful motivations to keep paying to service the debt. Bitcoin has no backing. Bitcoin is created out of thin air, the way people say of the dollar. The quantity of bitcoins created may be strictly limited by...
  • Is Historically Low Volatility About to Expand?
      Suspicion Asleep You have probably noticed it already: stock market volatility has recently all but disappeared. This raises an important question for every investor: Has the market established a permanent plateau of low volatility, or is the current period of low volatility just the calm before the storm?   All quiet on the VIX front... what can possibly happen? [PT] - click to enlarge.   When such questions regarding future market trends arise, it is often...
  • Why There Will Be No 11th Hour Debt Ceiling Deal
      Milestones in the Pursuit of Insolvency A new milestone on the American populaces’ collective pursuit of insolvency was reached this week. According to a report published on Tuesday by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, total U.S. household debt jumped to a new record high of $12.84 trillion during the second quarter. This included an increase of $552 billion from a year ago.   US consumer debt is making new all time highs – while this post GFC surge is actually...
  • Will They Haul Off Trump’s Statue, Too?
      Confused by Shadows POITOU, FRANCE – This week, we are talking about theperishable nature of gods. Yesterday, the city fathers of our hometown of Baltimore let it be known that it was time to toss out the old deities.   The Robert E. Lee and Thomas. J. “Stonewall” Jackson Monument in Baltimore, which the mayor inter alia wants to remove. Suddenly it has become fashionable to erase the memory of an important part of US history all over the country. By experience, this...
  • Bad Ideas About Money and Bitcoin
      How We Got Used to Fiat Money Most false or irrational ideas about money are not new. For example, take the idea that government can just fix the price of one monetary asset against another. Some people think that we can have a gold standard by such a decree today. This idea goes back at least as far as the Coinage Act of 1792, when the government fixed 371.25 grains of silver to the same value as 24.75 grains of gold, or a ratio of 15 to 1. This caused problems because the market...

Support Acting Man

j9TJzzN

Austrian Theory and Investment

Own physical gold and silver outside a bank

Archive

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com