Perverse Incentives

We haven’t written about Australia’s residential real estate bubble for some time (readers may want to check out last year’s post “Australia’s Bubble Trouble”, which contains numerous relevant charts and data).

 

Property Auction in Sidney-3Property auction in Sidney

 

Our friend Jonathan Tepper of Variant Perception has recently visited Australia for a fact-finding tour (more on this further below), so we felt we might as well take the opportunity to write an update on the topic.

 

1-Sydney House Prices Interest RatesHouse prices in Sidney vs. the administered interest rate of the Reserve Bank of Australia. As you will see below, interest rates aren’t the only driver of the bubble – click to enlarge.

 

Our reader D.S., who has moved to Australia five years ago, has provided us with a number of very interesting observations on the Australian housing market late last year, which we are sharing below. As D.S. notes, there are a number of interesting wrinkles specific to Australia’s real estate market, which outsiders are generally not likely to be aware of. We have highlighted a few passages in his report below which we think are especially important:

 

“The housing bubble in Australia has been talked about so extensively and has lasted so long without any harm coming to it that people here have pretty much dismissed the very possibility of a crash – including, it has to be said, the chances of a recession. The reason I was motivated to write this note is because there are some (I believe) unique dynamics at play in this housing market, which aren’t necessarily apparent to the outsider – at least, I was never aware of them until I moved here.

Australia has one of the highest levels of home ownership in the developed world and, in common with other Anglophone countries, the home is commonly viewed as people’s ‘primary asset’ i.e. the financial windfall they will one day be leaving to their children. When the property market is hot — as it has been in the past couple of years — people love nothing more than to talk about property values and how well they’re doing. Property developers, meanwhile, are presently building furiously in order to sell into current demand. Perhaps this is all that is propping up GDP growth right now (making the latest weak print all the more relevant).

To begin: Australia has a fairly unique approach to ensuring its citizens are provided for in retirement i.e. they have a system of mandatory saving for all workers – superannuation – which is supposed to provide the majority of contributors a healthy lump sum on which to retire. Funds are essentially deducted from each salary check and the proceeds typically invested in stocks by their friendly investment firm (think mutual fund, long-only, index-hugging types). There are a number of major issues with this system, not least declining forecast returns (in recent years), which means that future employee contributions will need to rise sharply, but that’s a discussion for another time.

Leaving aside the ideological objections to ‘forced saving’, this arrangement appears quite sensible as the State certainly doesn’t want to end up providing for those who would rather ignore retirement planning altogether. But the Superannuation system also means that Australians have one of the highest per capita equity exposures in the world (not that investment in equities is mandatory either but, culturally, equities is pretty much the only show in this town).

Again, this may not appear to be a bad thing, but here’s the problem: Australia’s banking oligopoly makes up fully 30+% of the entire main index (where the majority of Superannuation is invested) and the actual exposure to banks may be greater given that the ‘Big 4’ banking stocks have the most attractive dividend yields in the index. A quick glance at the ‘Big 4’ balance sheets reveals that the biggest single exposure they have is to is residential real estate (60+% in each case). This leaves the average Australian home-owner much more exposed to the real-estate market than most would appreciate.

But it doesn’t end there. Australia has a perverse tax subsidy called ‘negative gearing’, the origins of which I am not certain, but it effectively allows owners of investment properties to offset any losses they incur on that investment against personal income for tax purposes. This has made owning investment property de rigeur among many middle class Australians and, again, Australians have one of the highest levels of investment property ownership in the developed world (no doubt aided by this incentive). The incentive, of course, means that such property is very often acquired at what would be deemed, absent the subsidy, economically unattractive levels.

The ‘negative gearing’ subsidy is widely held by the public to be too politically sensitive to be considered for ‘review’, but talk of winding it back has started to crop up in the media for the first time in many years. In common with just about every other DM country the fiscal situation here is deteriorating and the government is under increasing pressure to address it. Negative gearing, depending on the source, costs the treasury some $8bn to $16bn per annum and the left-leaning opposition party, the ALP, is contemplating whether to make negative gearing one of the central policy planks at the next election (investment properties are largely deemed the domain of the better-off LNP supporter, after all).

And it gets worse: the government, in recent years, made Self Managed Superannuation Funds (SMSFs) more broadly accessible to its citizens so that they weren’t held hostage by the inherent limitations of mutual fund managers. In a subsequent development, SMSFs were then allowed (indeed, encouraged) to include residential property, which has led to a stampede by retirement savers into the investment property market — aided by a tsunami of positive media coverage. This change is undoubtedly partially responsible for the latest big leg up in the already substantial bubble. Apartment blocks have been going up like mushrooms all over metropolitan Australia to meet demand from investment buyers, Superannuation funds and the ubiquitous Chinese (collectively a whopping 40% of all buyers). Meanwhile, first-time buyers are reportedly, at their lowest levels (as a proportion of buyers) in history.

Glenn Stevens (the Reserve Bank of Australia governor) has been fairly open in admitting that this next leg up in the property boom is designed to build a bridge to a resource-sector recovery (whenever that may be) but that strikes me as a hell of a risk given the state of the global economy and its current trajectory. The property bubble is everything to this economy and the country’s citizens, whether they know it or not, are ‘all in’.

 

(emphasis added)

Well, good grief.

 

2-All Ords IndexAustralia’s All Ordinaries Index has made no net progress in the past decade. It first moved sharply higher on the back of the commodities bull market, while it is now primarily held up by the “big four” bank stocks, which in turn are probably regarded as the main beneficiaries of the housing bubble – as long as it continues, that is – click to enlarge.

 

In short, Australia’s citizens have far greater exposure to the bubble than is immediately obvious. On the one hand, property investment has become a kind of national pastime which people have taken to with gay abandon, seemingly oblivious to the risks. On the other hand, given that retirement savings are largely invested in the stock market, in which banks represent a 30% weight, they are exposed to the bubble indirectly through their pension plans as well.

Mortgage lending has grown at an enormous pace in Australia and as always happens in major credit bubbles, it has taken on ever more irresponsible forms (interest only loans have become ubiquitous – nearly half of all new mortgages are interest only loans these days). A serious downturn in house prices would undoubtedly lead to a major crisis in the banking system. People have gotten so used to the bubble’s seeming imperviousness, that neither insane practices nor insane prices seem to be fazing those involved any longer.

Those who so to speak “live inside the bubble” are no longer aware of its dangers. The mentality of Australians is generally well aligned with the country’s great weather – their outlook usually tends to be “happy-go-lucky” and optimistic. Given this fact and their experience to date, why would they heed the warnings of curmudgeons like us?

Consider for instance that eleven months have passed since we have last written about the situation. We suspected at the time that the demise of the commodities boom might finally trip Australia’s housing bubble up – and yet, here we are, with home prices in most regions of the country continuing to rise as if nothing had happened. However, this doesn’t mean that such warnings have become less relevant – on the contrary, they have become more so.

 

3-household debtAustralian household debt as a percentage of disposable income is at an all time high and has by now reached levels well beyond good and evil.

 

Evidence of a Bubble in its Late Stages

How much longer can the boom continue? D.S. has provided us with a personal anecdote that adds some color on this point:

 

“My neighbor is a valuer [ed note: appraiser] – he does property valuation work for banks and various other clients. I expressed concerns to him about the mind-boggling number of apartment blocks that have sprung up in our area (suburban, residential) in the past 12 months and he admitted that, privately, there are huge concerns in the industry over the glut that has developed, not just in our local area – the picture is the same all over the city (we are in Brisbane, Australia’s 3rd city). And many developments still haven’t even ‘broken dirt’ yet.  He mentioned that during – and long after – the 2008 financial crisis, banks demanded developers pre-sell nearly 100% of apartments before they would commit to financing them. Recently, standards have plummeted and banks are falling over themselves to make loans. Pre-sales requirements are now as low a 15%. Incentives like guaranteed minimum rental returns for the first 12 months are commonplace and, often these run to three years guaranteed.

There is also something quite curious about this latest building boom: in many instances blocks of apartments don’t appear to go on sale — having been built, there remains a complete absence of ‘For Sale’ signs at the properties and few or no adverts at all in the local media – as though they’ve been built and just abandoned. My neighbor confirmed that, in many cases, the apartments are not being marketed locally at all but to investors in other States and through dedicated Chinese agents. Then again, if they are selling, there would surely be ‘For Lease’ or ‘For Rent’ signs going up (there are few, if any) but more than 80% of local apartments (my observation) remain unoccupied.”

 

(emphasis added)

Indeed, tentative evidence is beginning to emerge that indicates that the bubble is probably entering its final stretch. Some of it is anecdotal, such as the observations related by D.S. above, but there are also a few warning signs detectable in the data. For instance, prices in some regions have begun to look a bit wobbly of late. More importantly, loan approvals for investors have noticeably decreased, something that has last happened during the 2008 financial crisis:

 

4-House prices and loan approvalsAustralian house prices by region and mortgage loan approvals – in some regions, prices are coming under pressure, while lending to investors has begun to decrease. Loan growth has mostly shifted to owner-occupiers instead – click to enlarge.

 

There is reason to believe that these recent developments are connected with the commodities bust. While the housing bubble has for a while taken on a life of its own, not least due to sharply declining interest rates and the effects of the government incentives outlined above, real estate prices in regions that are highly dependent on the mining business have been hit hard. This is apparently not felt in the large cities as of yet, but we suspect that the losses are beginning to add up – and that will inevitably begin to impact other regions as well (for some anecdotal color on this specific point, see also the video further below).

Data on broad money supply and credit growth likewise suggest that a major pillar supporting the boom is threatening to crumble – credit growth is lately only accelerating in the mortgage market, while it is flattening, resp. declining in other sectors. This has led to a slowdown in money supply growth in spite of the RBA’s loose monetary policy.

 

5-money supply and credit growthAustralian money supply growth and credit growth by sector: consumer lending has come to halt, while growth in business lending is beginning to stall out. Only mortgage lending growth has still accelerated recently – but for how long can this continue? – click to enlarge.

 

“Home Groans”

This brings us to Jonathan Tepper’s fact-finding tour. Australia’s 60 Minutes has interviewed him and accompanied him to a home auction for a report aptly entitled “Home Groans”. Jonathan has experienced Spain’s housing bubble first hand (and predicted its demise in timely fashion), so it is probably fair to say that he should be inured to bubble behavior. However, even he is seemingly stunned by what he is seeing.

The video segment begins with a report on Kate Maloney, the better half of a couple once crowned “Australia’s property investors of the year” (in 2012) – who now find themselves bankrupt, after borrowing over A$ 6 million which they invested in homes in a coal mining town in Queensland. In the meantime, house prices have crashed there: homes that used to sell for A$ 900,000 can be sold for A$ 180,000 nowadays – “if you’re lucky”, as Kate Maloney wistfully admits.

As Jonathan points out, the entire country seems to be in the grip of “collective madness”, as “everyone is borrowing more than they should”. What happened in the small coal mining town in Queensland will eventually happen everywhere. Given the astonishing extent of household indebtedness we have little doubt that this will lead to a major crisis – and quite likely it will be the worst economic and financial crisis to hit Australia in the entire post WW2 era.

To this it should be remembered that Australia’s banks are presumably still quite dependent on wholesale funding originated in London. This turned out to be a major Achilles heel of the banking system during the 2008 crisis, so perhaps they have in the meantime diversified their funding sources a bit. We still think that this is going to become a factor again once the crisis begins.

Readers should definitely invest the 15 minutes it will take to watch the 60 Minutes video below – it is really quite an eyeopener. A quite interesting detail is that banks are apparently prepared to approve loans even if they recognize the related dangers. They don’t really check whether people will be able to repay their mortgages in stress situations. This is typical late stage bubble behavior.

 

60 Minutes with Jonathan Tepper – “Home Groans”

 

We have to agree with Jonathan that there is really only one word to properly describe Australia’s housing bubble: Insane. As he says, all that remains to be determined is when exactly the bust will begin. Considering the data points presented above, we believe it will be sooner rather than later.

 

Conclusion

As the Australian property boom has once again shown, bubbles driven by loose monetary policy have a tendency to last much longer than seems possible to reasonable observers. In this particular case, the boom has already progressed to a rare extreme: with home prices at 10 to 12 times disposable income (far higher than the peaks attained in the housing bubbles in the US, Ireland and Spain), the end is clearly getting close.

Australian home-owners, property investors and banks will be in for quite a rude awakening. Readers should perhaps take a minute to commiserate with them and then give some thought to how money might be made from the situation. People based in Australia should definitely ponder how to best hedge themselves against the inevitable denouement.

We cannot give any concrete recommendations at this juncture, but there are obviously many possibilities (such as buying CDS on bank stocks or shorting financial sector and construction stocks, to name a few examples). This is something everyone will have to find out and decide for himself. We merely want to make the point that every crisis is at the same time an opportunity – and the best opportunities tend to present themselves while most people are still blissfully unaware of the impending disaster.

 

Addendum: Additional Footage

Jonathan’s Twitter feed has some additional video material on the property auction in Sidney that didn’t make it into the final cut of the 60 Minutes show (“Extra Minutes”).

 

Charts by Bullionbaron/Residex, stockcharts, RBA

 

 
 

Emigrate While You Can... Learn More

 
 

 

Dear Readers! We are happy to report that we have reached our turn-of-the-year funding goal and want to extend a special thank you to all of you who have chipped in. We are very grateful for your support! As a general remark, according to usually well informed circles, exercising the donation button in between funding drives is definitely legal and highly appreciated as well.

   

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

   
 

4 Responses to “Australia’s Housing Bubble: In the Grip of Insanity”

  • TheLege:

    Brisbane, Australia:
    I went out this morning, grabbed a coffee and this is what apartment-building activity I spied in my (suburban) neighbourhood:

    – 4 building sites cleared and awaiting planning approval and/or finance. No activity at this stage.
    – 2 building sites being readied for foundations to be poured.
    – 8 unit blocks at a fairly advanced building stage.
    – 3 apartment blocks very close to completion

    … all within an area smaller than a square kilometre. Within this same area there are, conservatively, 30 brand new apartments Unsold – I’ve tried to obtain a more accurate number but the estate agents are incredibly cagey: “Only a few left ….” etc. One of the ‘close to completion’ blocks (above) has 24 apartments, just for reference. The people who are trying to sell “previously owned” apartments are doomed, you would have to assume.

    And that is a small part of suburban Brisbane. I have heard first-hand that inner-city apartments are tough to rent out without meaningful price concessions.

    Just as aside, the recent property boom has been accompanied by an absolute explosion in the number of luxury European motor-cars on the roads — a lot of people with very ordinary jobs are driving quite extraordinary cars all of a sudden. Have they all big pay rises? Does it express confidence in the future? Have European manufacturers been ‘dumping’ vehicles here? Maybe it’s all of the above.

    However, the situation appears to have turned: 3 people I know (all white collar professionals) have been made redundant recently and the local super-market has seen a noticeable uptick in the number of male patrons during the working week (this could be something, I don’t know). Other firms I know of (in the Engineering sector) have enforced 4-day work weeks to save jobs. Firms prefer, for now, to hoard jobs while they await the mining recovery that is “just around the corner” …

    Will Glenn “I saved Australia from Recession in 08” Stevens regret his decision to ‘build a bridge’ over the commodity bust with this very deliberate property boom? Who knows, but this is surely what the Keynesian endgame is likely to look like:- try absolutely everything until the whole rotten edifice collapses on itself.

  • trojan1:

    Great article and I concur with your findings.. I also live in Brisbane.

    A major potential negative no one is looking at (and this can apply to many global property hot spots) is the coming acceleration of the bust from the “Chinese Non-Settlement” on property. As you said 40% of all properties have been sold to the Chinese.

    What will an investor in Shanghai do, who put his/her $90k deposit (10%) down on a $900k apartment, when it comes to settle and the property is worth $700k.. Is he going to stump up the remaining $810k.. Good luck on chasing them for the difference!!!

    To add further question marks, the RMB has been devalued 10% this year and the China Govt is tightening up on capital flows with the Chinese finding it harder to get funds out of China..

    http://www.domain.com.au/news/chinas-cash-controls-to-hit-sydney-property-20160121-gmbi00/

    Caveat Emptor!!

    • TheLege:

      trojan1

      Just to add to your comment: there is obviously a lot of faith being placed in the Chinese to keep Australia’s economy and property market propped up: “Build it and the Chinese will come!” etc

      However, in my experience (and at risk of racial stereo-typing) they tend to be very flakey as ‘investors’. They are definitely inveterate ‘punters’ and just love a ‘mania’ — they were the main driver of Fine Wine prices between 2006 and 2011 and when they stampeded out this market collapsed. When we marketed Chinese High Yield deals (my former professional life) they would fall over themselves to get into the deal and drive prices from Par to 115 overnight. A week later the same deal would be trading at 85. You wouldn’t witness this kind of behaviour (or those price moves) from any other set of investors in developed markets. And, of course, their domestic property boom is epic.

      The Japanese came to Australia in the 1980s and filled with their boots with property – when their economy collapsed later that decade Japanese money left and the Australian property market endured a torrid time. The Chinese situation is the same, only orders of magnitude larger. This time there will be nothing to save either the Aussie economy or the property market.

  • philc2:

    Pater,
    I can add some comments from Sydney, where I live. Recently the state government relaxed development rules for building high rise apartments within 800m of a rail station (a rational move in my opinion – put people where the services are and reduce red tape – but in the current climate there are consequences). As a result houses within that radius quickly sold to developers at ridiculous prices. In some streets groups of residents sold their adjoining houses in a “package deal” to developers and received up to A$2.5m, more than double the previous valuation. These houses are now mostly demolished and my suburb is now festooned with cranes. The apartments are sold “off the plan”, mostly to Asian investors. A two bedroom apartment in this suburb sells for about A$750k and we are a 40 minute train ride to the city centre!

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • French labour union workers and students attend a demonstration against the French labour law proposal in Marseille, France, as part of a nationwide labor reform protests and strikes, March 31, 2016. REUTERS/Jean-Paul Pelissier/File PhotoHow the Welfare State Dies
      Hollande Threatens to Ban Protests Brexit has diverted attention from another little drama playing out in Europe. As of the time of writing, if you Google “Hollande threatens to ban protests” or variations thereof, you will find Russian, South African and even Iranian press reports on the topic. Otherwise, it's basically crickets (sole exception: Politico).  Gee, we wonder why?   They don't like him anymore: 120.000 protesters recently turned Paris into a war zone. All...
  • The-answer-is-yesToward Freedom: Will The UK Write History?
      Mutating Promises We are less than one week away from the EU referendum, the moment when the British people will be called upon to make a historic decision – will they vote to “Brexit” or to “Bremain”? Both camps have been going at each other with fierce campaigns to tilt the vote in their direction, but according to the latest polls, with the “Leave” camp’s latest surge still within the margin of error, the outcome is too close to call.   The battle lines are...
  • water houseA Market Ready to Blow and the Flag of the Conquerors
      Bold Prediction MICHAELS, Maryland – The flag in front of our hotel flies at half-mast. The little town of St. Michaels is a tourist and conference destination on the Chesapeake Bay. It is far from Orlando, and even farther from Daesh (a.k.a. ISIL) and the Mideast.   St. Michaels, Maryland – the town that fooled the British (they say, today). Photo credit: Fletcher6   Out on the river, a sleek sailboat, with lacquered wood trim, glides by, making hardly a...
  • nails-in-a-bed-of-nails-new-yorker-cartoonGoing... Going... Gone! The EU Begins to Splinter
      Dark Social Mood Tsunami Washes Ashore Early this morning one might have been forgiven for thinking that Japan had probably just been hit by another tsunami. The Nikkei was down 1,300 points, the yen briefly soared above par. Gold had intermittently gained 100 smackers – if memory serves, the biggest nominal intra-day gain ever recorded (with the possible exception of one or two days in early 1980). Here is a picture of Haruhiko Kuroda in front of his Bloomberg monitor this...
  • queen_gold-840x501Rule Britannia
      A Glorious Day What a glorious day for Britain and anyone among you who continues to believe in the ideas of liberty, freedom, and sovereign democratic rule. The British people have cast their vote and I have never ever felt so relieved about having been wrong. Against all expectations, the leave camp somehow managed to push the referendum across the center line, with 51.9% of voters counted electing to leave the European Union.   Waving good-bye to...
  • junkThe Problem with Corporate Debt
      Taking Off Like a Rocket There are actually two problems with corporate debt. One is that there is too much of it... the other is that a lot of it appears to be going sour.   Harvey had a good time in recent years...well, not so much between mid 2014 and early 2016, but happy days are here again! Cartoon by Frank Modell   As a brief report at Marketwatch last week (widely ignored as far as we are aware) informs us:   “Businesses racked up debt in the...
  • MACAU, CHINA - JANUARY 28: Buildings of Macau Casino on January 28, 2013, Gambling tourism is Macau's biggest source of revenue, making up about fifty percent of the economy.What Could Possibly Go Wrong?
      A Convocation Of Gamblers The Wall Street Journal and BloombergView have just run articles on the shadow banking system in China.  This has put me in a nostalgic mood. About 35 years ago when I was living in Japan, I made a side trip to Hong Kong.   Asia's Sin City, Macau Photo credit: Nattee Chalermtiragool   I took the hydrofoil to Macau one afternoon and the same service back early the next morning.  On the morning trip, I am sure that I saw many of the...
  • saupload_loves-me-loves-me-notA Darwin Award for Capital Allocation
      Beyond Human Capacity Distilling down and projecting out the economy’s limitless spectrum of interrelationships is near impossible to do with any regular accuracy.  The inputs are too vast.  The relationships are too erratic.   The economy - complex and ever-changing interrelations. Image credit: Andrea Dionne   Quite frankly, keeping tabs on it all is beyond human capacity.  This also goes for the federal government.  Even with all their data gatherers and...
  • rate_hike_cartoon_10.15.2015_largeJanet Yellen’s $200-Trillion Debt Problem
      Blame “Brexit” BALTIMORE – The U.S. stock market broke its losing streak on Thursday [and even more so on Monday, ed.]. After five straight losing sessions, the Dow eked out a 92-point gain. The financial media didn’t know what to say about it. So, we ended up with the typical inanities, myths, and claptrap.   “Investors” are pushing the DJIA back up again..apparently any excuse will do at the moment. The idea may backfire though, as exactly the same thing happened...
  • deflated-souffleThe Fed’s  Doomsday Device
      Bezzle BALTIMORE –  Barron’s, in a lather, says the market is facing the “Two Horsemen of the Apocalypse.” Huh?   Only two? There were four last time!   Supposedly, the so-called Brexit – the vote in Britain this Thursday on whether to leave or remain in the European Union (EU) – and uncertainty over where the Fed will take U.S. interest rates are cutting down stocks faster than a Z-turn mower. But Brexit is a side show. As our contacts in London...
  • Brexit supporterGold and Brexit
      Going Up for the Wrong Reason Gold is soaring. It should—and a lot—but in my view not for the reason it is. Indeed gold is insurance for uncertain times, a time that Brexit seems to represent. But insurance is an administrative cost — one must minimize its use.   August gold contract, daily – gold has been strong of late, but this seems to be driven by “Brexit” fears - click to enlarge.   Moreover, insuring against Brexit might ironically be equivalent...
  • cameron at the EUBrexit Paranoia Creeps Into the Markets
      European Stocks Look Really Bad... Late last week stock markets around the world weakened and it seemed as though recent “Brexit” polls showing that the “leave” campaign has obtained a slight lead provided the trigger. The idea was supported by a notable surge in the British pound's volatility.   Battening down the hatches...   On the other hand, if one looks at European stocks, one could just as well argue that their bearish trend is simply continuing – and...

Austrian Theory and Investment

Support Acting Man

Own physical gold and silver outside a bank

Archive

j9TJzzN

350x200

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com