Mark Hulbert on the HGNSI

As an addendum to Dan Popescu’s article on the state of gold sentiment, we want to show an update of the indicators we follow. Coincidendally, Mark Hulbert has also just published an update on his HGNSI measure (Hulbert Gold Newsletter Sentiment Index). The Index measures the percentage newsletter writers recommend to allocate to gold-related investments on average – either on the long or the short side. As it turns out, the current level of the HGNSI stands at nearly minus 47%, which happens to be the second-highest bearish sentiment expression in 30 years (the highest was recorded in June 2013).

 

Mark Hulbert notes:

 

“[…] the average recommended gold market exposure level among a subset of short-term gold market timers tracked by the Hulbert Financial Digest (as measured by the Hulbert Gold Newsletter Sentiment Index, or HGNSI). This average currently stands at minus 46.9%, which means that the average short-term gold timer is now allocating nearly half his clients’ gold-oriented portfolios to going short.

That is an aggressively bearish posture, which is unlikely to be profitable according to contrarian analysis.

There’s been only one time in the past 30 years when the HGNSI got any lower than it is today. That came in June 2013, when the HGNSI fell to minus 56.7%. As you can see from the accompanying chart, gold soon — within a matter of a couple weeks — began a rally that, by late August, had tacked more than $200 on to the price of an ounce of gold.

Notice that gold’s 2013 summer rally didn’t begin immediately after the HGNSI dropped to the levels we’re seeing today. That’s hardly a criticism, of course, since no trading system can pick the market’s turning points with pinpoint accuracy. Nevertheless, according to the econometric tests to which I have subjected the 30 years’ worth of my sentiment data, the gold market performs appreciably better following low HGNSI readings rather than it does high ones. Contrarian analysis hasn’t always worked, needless to say, but it’s more successful than it is a failure.”

 

There are of course good reasons for gold timers to be bearish. For one thing, gold has been mired in a descending triangle over the past year or so. From a technical perspective, such triangles are likely to be continuation patterns. Note however that the 1999/2000 low was also made after a descending triangle had formed in the course of about a year, so this pattern does not always resolve bearishly.

Gold fundamentals have recently worsened a bit though. The most obvious headwind is the continued strength in the US dollar, but this isn’t the only indicator that has turned more bearish lately (others are e.g. the flattening US yield curve, general weakness in commodities, the continued strength in risk assets and the associated faith in the omniscience of central bankers). Credit spreads on the other hand are still a supportive factor. However, no-one is going to ring a bell when the low is eventually made, and it seems likely that the news will mostly be bad for gold when it happens. Sentiment is definitely exrtemely subdued. Here is the chart of the HGNSI:

 

1-HGNSIThe HGNSI is now at minus 46.9%, the second worst reading in the past 30 years – click to enlarge.

 

A similar picture is indicated by Sentimentrader’s industry group sentiment table, which shows that gold and energy stocks are currently at the maximum bearish level they can reach by this measure:

 

2-Stock and Sector SentimentSentiment on stocks in various industry groups – gold and energy are currently stuck at “zero bullish sentiment” – click to enlarge.

 

Other Sentiment and Positioning Measures

The next chart shows an update of the discounts to net asset value of closed end bullion funds, as well as Rydex precious metals assets and cumulative cash flows compared to the gold price.

 

3-Gold, closed-ends,Rydex-1

The discounts to NAV of CEF and GTU (closed end bullion funds). It is worth noting that both CEF and GTU have recently reflected even greater bearish sentiment than at the 2013 lows. By contrast, Rydex precious metals assets and cumulative cash flows still rest at slightly higher lows, which is partly due to gold stocks still diverging somewhat from gold – click to enlarge.

 

The positions of commercial hedgers and small speculators in gold futures continue to reflect the effects of the ongoing downtrend, but with regard to these data it must be kept in mind that these positions could still worsen markedly in a long term bear market. These positions are only extreme compared to those of recent years.

 

4-Gold CoTHedgers and small speculators in gold futures – click to enlarge.

 

Relative Prices and Ratios

Gold stocks have weakened significantly in recent weeks, not only on an absolute basis, but also relative to gold. However, they still diverge from gold relative to the situation at the May low. Moreover, after briefly correcting against commodities, gold has recently begun to rise again versus the CCI. This is usually a subtle sign of declining economic confidence, akin to credit spreads.

Below are charts showing gold and the HUI, a comparison of GDXJ, HUI and the HUI-gold ratio, as well as gold versus commodities (gold-CCI ratio). GDXJ is still slightly diverging from the HUI as well (its divergence with GDX, which is not shown, looks similar).

A rising gold-CCI ratio is usually positive for gold mining margins, even if the nominal gold price is weak. However, when bearish sentiment becomes very pronounced, the market tends not to care much about this. Readers can easily ascertain that on an anecdotal level, a lot of bearish sentiment is in evidence as well. On average, the major financial news services (Marketwatch, Bloomberg, Reuters, etc.) publish between one to two bearish articles on gold every day recently, which is quite a density even by the standards of the past two years.

It can probably be taken as a given that the vast majority of market observers and participants expects the descending triangle to result in a break of support. Note in this context that silver has clearly broken through its long term support shelf already, which has presumably cemented the negative views on gold.

 

5-Gold and HUI compared-triangleThe descending triangle in gold and gold’s slight medium term divergence with the HUI index – click to enlarge.

 

6-GDXJ-HUI-HUI-goldGDXJ, the HUI and the HUI-gold ratio. GDXJ has been stronger than the HUI, which in turn has been stronger than gold (on a medium term basis, not in the short term) – hence they all continue to diverge from each other for now – click to enlarge.

 

7-Gold-CCIThe gold-CCI ratio: after a one month long correction, gold has resumed its uptrend relative to commodities (in this case it means it is falling more slowly). However, after diverging positively from the ratio in June, gold stocks are currently diverging negatively from it – click to enlarge.

 

Gold and the US Dollar

After resisting the headwind from a rising dollar for quite some time, gold has finally succumbed, not least because the dollar’s uptrend has become quite relentless. The dollar index has in fact broken above a long term resistance level, so this is a serious problem for gold at the moment (gold continues to look a lot stronger denominated in foreign currencies). However, in spite of this, the dollar-gold ratio has not moved very far above its previous peak yet. In other words, gold has not been as weak as one would have expected based on dollar strength alone. This confirms that the dollar is far from the only factor influencing the gold price, even though it is obviously a pretty important one.

 

8-Dollar-gold ratioThe US dollar index and its ratio to gold. The dollar’s recent strength has been relentless. Bullish sentiment on the dollar is accordingly quite skewed as well. However, foreign exchange trends have a tendency to be relentless once they get underway, so one should probably not read too much into current high bullish sentiment and overbought conditions, even though they argue at least for a short term reaction. See also the current bullish sentiment readings on the dollar mentioned below – click to enlarge.

 

Conclusion:

Gold looks technically quite weak, and whether the slight divergences that are still in evidence at the moment are meaningful remains to be seen. However, since sentiment has reached extremes in both gold and the dollar, a short term trend change is likely quite close.

Note here that an average of the most important sentiment surveys shows the bullish consensus on the US dollar to be at 87% at present, which is in fact a record high. Investors are even more bullish on the dollar today than they were at its highs in 2000 and 2001.

The comparable statistic for gold is at 18% bulls, which is not a record low, but definitely among the lowest readings on record (most of the lowest bullish sentiment readings in gold were produced in 1998/99 and 2013).

Once a rebound gets underway, its technical quality and the evolution of the fundamental and sentiment backdrop will have to be assessed to see whether it is just another short term blip or something more. As Dan Popescu noted, it is certainly possible that gold violates the support levels of 2013 (given that it is only a little over 30 dollars above them), but such a break is not likely to be sustained in the short term in light of the current sentiment backdrop.

 

Charts by: Mark Hulbert, Sentimentrader, StockCharts

 

 

 

Emigrate While You Can... Learn More

 


 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 12vB2LeWQNjWh59tyfWw23ySqJ9kTfJifA

   
 

6 Responses to “More on Gold Sentiment”

  • No6:

    Gold is waiting for QE4 or a variation thereof, which will shock the financial world because of what it will reveal about the real state of the US economy.

  • I think Gold is on a triangle. What bothers me is that everybody seems to think the same. That is a problem but for the time being, I think that is the most probable possiblity. That said I think we are in wave “D” of that thoretical triangle. That means that there should be another thrust up, muximum to the begining of D wave.

    From the sentiment perspective, sometimes extreme sentiment do not represent the bottom or the top. On these ocations is the new low/high with a higher/lower sentiment reading what really forecasts the “bottom/top”. This is why I stick to the triangle possibility even though so much people bet on it. I think there is going to be a new rally (wave E). And if that rally is strong enough to reach the begining of wave D, then the upper boundary of the triangle would be broken. Sentiment, then should improve considerably. That could be the fuel for the next leg down, probably the last one.

    But all of these is just guess work. I think that picture can come up. But it is too far away to be sure. For the moment the rally leg seems really probable.

    You can check one little summary here:

    http://themarketsbullfighter.blogspot.com.es/2014/09/actualizacion-de-metales.html

    From a Demark long time perspective, last summer we saw the completion of a TD Set Up not perfected. It still lacks that perfection. So a little travel below 1180 is not so unprobable, from a Demark perspective. You can check what I have to say about gold last summer:

    http://themarketsbullfighter.blogspot.com.es/2014/01/repaso-del-gdx-y-del-oro.html

    For the time being gold is lateral and the better way to trade laterals is to buy on support and sell on ressistance. Now gold is on support

  • Kreditanstalt:

    It has been reported lately in credible sources IMO – that Chinese & Indian demand for bullion is now close to consuming the entire world mined annual supply. And don’t suppose that “the above ground supply of gold is enormous”. It’s POTENTIALLY enormous, yes…but at these artificially low prices it must be miniscule.

    We HAVE “soaring price inflation” already – if you look around you. The effects of money-printing don’t flow evenly into all areas: we have soaring house prices, soaring stock prices, soaring asset “values”, art & collectibles prices, healthcare costs, higher education costs, public sector pension costs, taxes and numerous others – and we’re beginning to see higher prices dribbling into consumer goods too…recently coffee, beef, chicken, pork…

    Yes, there IS some small degree of overt manipulation of the USD gold price but the most significant factor in favour of those wishing to suppress the true price of the very small supply of metal available is that the governments have granted them the ability to flog unlimited amounts of paper gold without having anywhere even close to the necessary metal to back all of their issued contracts.

    And THAT is institutionalized fraud.

  • Kreditanstalt:

    Then why do I keep reading stories about Indian smuggling, “wedding season” gold demand reaching new highs, Chinese gold demand maintained or expanded, Shanghai silver stocks nearly gone, Indian premiums soaring and the like?

    Hulbert is a blowhard, a case of when the observer begins to affect the observed. At least among the bettors he surveys. Eventually physical demand must overrun paper selling. We just don’t know when in this most opaque of markets.

    But technical analysis is of little use in totally manipulated “markets”.

    • tkinder:

      Is it possible that some of the sites touting Indian and Chinese gold demand, Shanghai silver stocks nearly gone, soaring premiums, etc. have some interest in promoting their particular point of view?

      I believe the idea of a paper/physical price split has existed at least since the late 1990’s, if not earlier.

      Thus far, there has not been a split.

      One of the errors of analyzing gold demand is not putting enough weight behind the idea that: 1) Most gold trading is hidden from the market; and going along with that 2) The above ground supply of gold is enormous – newly mined gold and yearly demand is relatively small in relation to existing supply.

      Evaluating the gold price primarily based on supply and demand, as if it were an industrial metal, does not accurately take into account the large supply of gold or why people are actually purchasing it.

      The gold price is like a barometer reacting to the economic atmosphere. When people fear inflation, currency devaluation, bad government economic policies, geopolitical instability, etc., then the price of gold reacts.

      My idea for a long time is that for a substantial price move in gold, at least four elements will be necessary – perhaps not sufficient, but necessary:

      1) Increasing interest rates – This will be a sign that central banks recognize a real danger of higher inflation rates and are forced to react to them;

      2) Negative real interest rates;

      3) Higher inflation – The kind of inflation that will be reported by the mainstream media because it cannot be ignored any longer;

      4) Increasing velocity of money – Lack of money velocity has been a primary reason that forecasts of very high inflation or hyperinflation have failed to prove true.

      As for technical analysis – I disagree. Manipulated markets or not, technical analysis – done properly – can prove very useful in forecasting both the future price and momentum of gold.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • America Goes Full Imbecile
      Credit has a wicked way of magnifying a person’s defects.  Even the most cautious man, with unlimited credit, can make mistakes that in retrospect seem absurd.  But an average man, with unlimited credit, is preeminently disposed to going full imbecile.   Let us not forget about this important skill...  [PT]   Several weeks ago we came across a woeful tale of Mike Meru.  Somehow, this special fellow, while of apparent sound mine and worthy intent, racked up...
  • In Gold We Trust, 2018
      The New In Gold We Trust Report is Here! As announced in our latest gold market update last week, this year's In Gold We Trust report by our good friends Ronald Stoeferle and Mark Valek has just been released. This is the biggest and most comprehensive gold research report in the world, and as always contains a wealth of interesting new material, as well as the traditional large collection of charts and data that makes it such a valuable reference work for gold...
  • “Sell in May” Chart Update - The Impressive Market Weakness in the Summer Half-Year All Over the World
      The Details Plotted In the last issue of Seasonal Insights I showed you the statistics associated with the popular truism “sell in May and go away” in the countries with the eleven largest stock markets. The comparison divided the calendar year into a summer half-year from May to October and a winter half-year from November to April. In all eleven countries, the winter half-year outperformed the summer half-year. As announced on that occasion, here are the details for all countries...
  • Who’s That Ringing the Korean Bell of Friendship?
      Friends and Enemies Do citizens of the United States trust their government will do what’s right?  It depends who you ask. By and large, the esteem the American populace holds its government in is likely a small fraction of what it was roughly 65 years ago.  That was when Lieutenant General William Kelly Harrison Jr. signed the Korean Armistice Agreement.  Certainly, in days gone by representatives of other nations held the U.S. government in higher regard.   The most...
  • Credit Spreads: Polly is Twitching Again - in Europe
      Junk Bond Spread Breakout The famous dead parrot is coming back to life... in an unexpected place. With its QE operations, which included inter alia corporate bonds, the ECB has managed to suppress credit spreads in Europe to truly ludicrous levels. From there, the effect propagated through arbitrage to other developed markets. And yes, this does “support the economy” - mainly by triggering an avalanche of capital malinvestment and creating the associated boom conditions, while...
  • Retail Capitulation – Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Small Crowds, Shrinking Premiums The prices of gold and silver rose five bucks and 37 cents respectively last week. Is this the blast off to da moon for the silver rocket of halcyon days, in other words 2010-2011?   Various gold bars. Coin and bar premiums have been shrinking steadily (as have coin sales of the US Mint by the way), a sign that retail investors have lost interest in gold. There are even more signs of this actually, and this loss of interest stands in stark...
  • Wild Speculation in Crude Oil - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Crude Oil Market Structure – Extremes in Speculative Net Long Positions On May 28, markets were closed so this Report is coming out a day later than normal. The price of gold rose nine bucks, and the price of silver 4 pennies. With little action here, we thought we would write 1,000 words’ worth about oil. Here is a chart showing oil prices and open interest in crude oil futures.   WTIC (West Texas Intermediate crude) price and futures open interest – the vast increase...
  • Industrial Commodities vs. Gold - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Oil is Different Last week, we showed a graph of rising open interest in crude oil futures. From this, we inferred — incorrectly as it turns out — that the basis must be rising. Why else, we asked, would market makers carry more and more oil?   Crude oil acts differently from gold – and so do all other industrial commodities. What makes them different is that the supply of industrial commodities held in storage as a rule suffices to satisfy industrial demand only for a...
  • Gold Divergences Emerge
      Bad Hair Day Produces Positive Divergences On Friday the ongoing trade dispute between the US and China was apparently escalated by a notch to the next level, at least verbally. The Trump administration announced a list of tariffs that are supposed to come into force in three week's time and China clicked back by announcing retaliatory action. In effect, the US government said: take that China, we will now really hurt our own consumers!  - and China's mandarins replied: just you wait, we...
  • Chasing the Wind
      Futility with Purpose Plebeians generally ignore the tact of their economic central planners.  They care more that their meatloaf is hot and their suds are cold, than about any plans being hatched in the capital city.  Nonetheless, the central planners know an angry mob, with torches and pitchforks, are only a few empty bellies away.  Hence, they must always stay on point.   Watch for those pitchfork bearers – they can get real nasty and then heads often roll quite literally....
  • Lift-Off Not (Yet) - Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Wrong-Way Event Last week we said something that turned out to be prescient:   This is not an environment for a Lift Off Event.   An unfortunate technical mishap interrupted the latest moon-flight of the gold rocket. Fear not true believers, a few positive tracks were left behind. [PT]   The price of gold didn’t move much Mon-Thu last week, though the price of silver did seem to be blasting off. Then on Friday, it reversed hard. We will provide a forensic...

Support Acting Man

Item Guides

TechyBeasts
j9TJzzN

The Review Insider

Dog Blow

Austrian Theory and Investment

Archive

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

Mish Talk

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com