Newsletter Writers Turn Very Bearish

This is a little addendum to our recent gold update. Shortly after we had posted it, Mark Hulbert published an article at Marketwatch regarding the recent moves in the Gold Newsletter Writer Sentiment Index (HGNSI). Note here that this sentiment measure must be seen in the context of market action. As we have pointed out previously, there have been a number of very significant ‘misses’ of this indicator, especially in early 2003 and early 2004, when following its message would have been a grave mistake.

However, there is also the fact to consider that today’s gold-focused newsletter writers are probably not the same bunch that was active 10 years ago. Many of those who were active in 2003 had survived a 20 year long bear market, so their collective judgment was at times actually quite good.

To Mr. Hulbert’s credit, we must concede that his indicator has worked better in recent years, and his interpretations of it in the course of this year have largely been on the mark. That’s actually a good thing, as the indicator is currently showing an extreme in negative sentiment.

Here is the chart:

 

1-HGNSIHulbert Gold Newsletter Writer Sentiment Index – currently it stands at – 40.6% – click to enlarge.

 

What the percentage means is that at the moment, gold timers are recommending that their clients allocate 40.6% of their gold-related assets to shorting gold. Although the measure fell to even lower levels in the summer of 2013 and also in 1998/1999 if memory serves, this is still a historically fairly extreme level.

Mr. Hulbert notes:

 

“Consider the average recommended gold market exposure level among a subset of short-term gold market timers tracked by the Hulbert Financial Digest (as measured by the Hulbert Gold Newsletter Sentiment Index, or HGNSI). This average currently stands at minus 40.6%, which means that the typical gold timer is recommending that clients allocate nearly half their gold-oriented portfolios to going short the market.

That’s a particularly aggressive bet that gold will keep declining, and — at least according to contrarian analysis — these timers are unlikely to be right. As recently as last week, the HGNSI had not fallen below minus 21.9%. That was less than the lows to which this sentiment index fell last December (minus 36.7%) and in the summer of 2013 (minus 56.7%). And that, in turn, led me to conclude that contrarians were not yet ready to bet on even a short-term rally.

[…]

The usual qualifications apply, of course. Sentiment is not the only thing that moves the markets. And even when contrarian analysis is right, it doesn’t necessarily have pinpoint accuracy. But, because sentiment analysis has been on the correct side of this gold market in recent months, it’s definitely noteworthy that it’s now more optimistic.”

 

(emphasis added)

Now for the context: since gold is mired in another short term downtrend, it is not surprising that bearishness is high. However, gold also remains above the lows made in 2013, and gold stocks have built multiple divergences with the gold price, in the process beginning to hold up somewhat better on a relative basis. So the context is at least to some extent a mixed bag and not entirely negative.

Note by the way that yesterday’s decline in cap-weighted gold stock indexes like HUI and XAU was distorted by Anglogold (AU) announcing that it will hive off its non-South African assets into a new company. Normally such an announcement would be seen as bullish for the stock, the problem is though that in order to get approval from the SA Reserve Bank for the deal, AU had to find a way to extinguish a lot of debt. In order to to that, it plans to do a very large share issue. That was not what the market wanted to hear, and the stock was clobbered by more than 15.5%.

 

Given that AU is one of the world’s largest gold mining firms, it has a pretty large weighting in the indexes and has been responsible for about 50% of yesterday’s decline. Needless to say, the timing of the announcement is a real head-scratcher. We have no idea why AU’s management decided to make it just as the stock was hitting multi-month lows. However, we have often seen such announcements being made at especially inopportune times. Apparently the managers of many gold mining companies don’t consider that it can actually cost shareholders money when such announcements are mistimed (since greater dilution will now be required than would otherwise be the case).

 

2-AUAU crashes on news of a capital raise that has become necessary to receive SARB approval for its planned demerger – click to enlarge.

 

Other Sentiment and Positioning Data

Below is a quick overview of other sentiment and positioning data. Commitments of traders in gold have seen hedgers covering and speculators selling, and as of last week Tuesday, the net speculative long position (small and large speculators combined) stood at 103 K contracts. This is not very much compared to recent years, and it is highly likely that it will have become noticeably smaller in the meantime.

Note though that there is no telling where this indicator will go. If a new bear market leg lies ahead (i.e., a multi-week downtrend), then this position could conceivably be reversed altogether (from net long to net short). So it currently looks mildly encouraging compared to the levels of recent years, but it there is always the caveat that it can worsen further in the event of a more protracted bear market. Luckily for bulls, it coincides with the above mentioned extreme in the HGNSI and several other sentiment extremes – so at the very least the downside should be somewhat limited.

 

3-Gold-CoTCommitments of traders in gold – the hedger net position in blue, the small speculator net position in red. The latter group is by now probably either flat or slightly net short (we are guessing, as this snapshot is more than a week old. Unfortunately the release of CoT data is not very timely) – click to enlarge.

 

Lastly, a look at the discounts to NAV of closed end bullion funds, as well as Rydex precious metals assets and cumulative cash flows. Normally we consider it better when these discounts contract, but when they hit what are historically extreme levels, then they serve as contrary indicators as well. Again, similar to what Mr. Hulbert notes w.r.t. the HGNSI, these are by no means very accurate timing indicators. They can only tell us whether there is froth or fear in the market, and right now there seems to be quite a bit of fear.

We’ve adapted a chart that was recently posted by Erin Swenlin (formerly of Decisionpoint, now with Stockcharts) and have left the trendlines she drew on the gold price chart in. It should be noted that the triangle formed over the past year or so with its two lower highs does not look particularly encouraging, so once again, it is not a big surprise that bearish sentiment is quite pronounced at the moment. While the long term chart picture is currently discouraging, it wouldn’t take much to turn it completely around. On the other hand, if the 2013 lows were to break, that would obviously be very bad news.

The engagement of Rydex traders in the sector meanwhile is reminiscent of 1999/2000. Note though that it is not enough that sentiment is bad – that by itself will not turn the market around.

 

4-Gold sentiment dataDiscounts to NAV of CEF and GTU (two closed end bullion funds) plus Rydex precious metals assets and cumulative cash net cash flows – click to enlarge.

 

Conclusion:

Bulls should actually hope that these sentiment trends bottom out and reverse, but that a certain amount of skepticism remains if and when they do. However, in the meantime the relatively extreme levels of the data suggest that the potential additional downside should actually be limited in the short term. It then remains to be seen how things evolve in the next bounce.

 

Addendum: 

Note that this article was written prior to Thursday’s market open, so the charts reflect Wednesday’s close. Thursday’s market action does however not substantially alter the situation described above, except insofar that it can be inferred that several of the data points may have deteriorated slightly further.

 
 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

   
 

2 Responses to “Gold Sentiment Plunges to Summer 2013 Levels”

  • Kreditanstalt:

    Strange, isn’t it…? These “speculators”, “hedgers” and “traders” go SHORT anything that is FALLING! And only BUY when something has already started RISING!

    Completely bass-ackward. Totally reliant on suppressed volatility. And completely dismissive of anything other than their desperate, grubby, craven search for YIELD, any yield, at any cost.

    Hulbert? Hulbert is a contrary indicator.

  • Kreditanstalt:

    Well, I confess to buying some more of a major gold producer (with assets in – gasp! – RUSSIA!) on Tuesday. I couldn’t bear to see the stock going begging at a fraction of its former price.

    If we’re not below cost of production I won’t believe it. If we measure our gold in ounces – or anything but Amerikan dollars – we’re doing OK. If every government on the planet being in a race-to-debase isn’t enough to drive some of that paper into even ‘paper gold’, I will be gobstruck.

    Sometimes you have to dump the charts, the graphs, the crystal balls and the backwad-looking predictions (“this resembles 1974-77” etc.) and go with your intuition and let logic and reality dictate your moves.

    It’s too damned counterintuitive and too damned OBVIOUS.

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • The Biggest Stock Market Crashes Tend to Happen in October
      October is the Most Dangerous Month The prospect of steep market declines worries investors – and the month of October has a particularly bad reputation in this respect.   Bad juju month: Statistically, October is actually not the worst month on average – but it is home to several of history's most memorable crashes, including the largest ever one-day decline on Wall Street. A few things worth noting about 1987: 1. the crash did not presage a recession. 2. its...
  • Fed Quack Treatments are Causing the Stagnation
      Bleeding the Patient to Health There’s something alluring about cure-alls and quick fixes. Who doesn’t want a magic panacea to make every illness or discomfort disappear? Such a yearning once compelled the best and the brightest minds to believe the impossible for over two thousand years.   Instantaneous relief! No matter what your affliction is, snake oil cures them all. [PT]   For example, from antiquity until the late-19th century, bloodletting was used to...
  • Canada: Risks of a Parliamentary Democracy
      A Vulnerable System Parliamentary democracy is vulnerable to the extremely dangerous possibility that someone with very little voter support can rise to the top layer of government. All one apparently has to do is to be enough of a populist to get elected by ghetto dwellers.   Economist and philosopher Hans-Hermann Hoppe dissects democracy in his book Democracy, the God that Failed, which shines a light on the system's grave deficiencies with respect to guarding liberty. As...
  • Federal Reserve President Kashkari’s Masterful Distractions
      The True Believer How is it that seemingly intelligent people, of apparent sound mind and rational thought, can stray so far off the beam?  How come there are certain professions that reward their practitioners for their failures? The central banking and monetary policy vocation rings the bell on both accounts.  Today we offer a brief case study in this regard.   Minneapolis Fed president Neel Kashkari attacking a block of wood with great zeal. [PT] Photo credit: Linda Davidson...
  • Thoughtful Disagreement with Ted Butler
      Too Big to Fail?   Dear Mr. Butler, in your article of 2 October, entitled Thoughtful Disagreement, you say:   “Someone will come up with the thoughtful disagreement that makes the body of my premise invalid or the price of silver will validate the premise by exploding.”   Ted Butler – we first became aware of Mr. Butler in 1998, and as far as we know, he has been making the bullish case for silver ever since. Back in the late 90s this was actually a...
  • Donald Trump: Warmonger-in-Chief
      Cryptic Pronouncements If a world conflagration, God forbid, should break out during the Trump Administration, its genesis will not be too hard to discover: the thin-skinned, immature, shallow, doofus who currently resides in the Oval Office!   The commander-in-chief - a potential source of radiation?   This past week, the Donald has continued his bellicose talk with both veiled and explicit threats against purported American adversaries throughout the world.  In...
  • Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      Fat-Boy Waves The prices of the metals dropped $17 and $0.35, and the gold-silver ratio rose to 77.  A look at the chart of either metal shows that a downtrend in prices (i.e. uptrend in the dollar) that began in mid-April reversed in mid-July. Then the prices began rising (i.e. dollar began falling). But that move ended September 8.   Stars of the most popular global market sitcoms, widely suspected of being “gold wave-makers”. From left to right: Auntie Janet...
  • The Donald Can’t Stop It
      Divine Powers The Dow’s march onward and upward toward 30,000 continues without a pause.  New all-time highs are notched practically every day.  Despite Thursday’s 31-point pullback, the Dow is up over 15.5 percent year-to-date.  What a remarkable time to be alive.   The DJIA keeps surging... but it is running on fumes (US money supply growth is disappearing rapidly). The president loves this and has decided to “own” the market by gushing about its record run. During...
  • 1987, 1997, 2007... Just How Crash-Prone are Years Ending in 7?
      Bad Reputation Years ending in 7, such as the current year 2017, have a bad reputation among stock market participants. Large price declines tend to occur quite frequently in these years.   Sliding down the steep slope of the cursed year. [PT]   Just think of 1987, the year in which the largest one-day decline in the US stock market in history took place:  the Dow Jones Industrial Average plunged by 22.61 percent in a single trading day. Or recall the year 2007,...
  • Stocks Up and Yields Down – Precious Metals Supply & Demand
      Where the Good Things Go Many gold bugs make an implicit assumption. Gold is good, therefore it will go up. This is tempting but wrong (ignoring that gold does not go anywhere, it’s the dollar that goes down). One error is in thinking that now you have discovered a truth, everyone else will see it quickly. And there is a subtler error. The error is to think good things must go up. Sometimes they do, but why?   Since putting in a secular low at the turn of the millennium,...
  • The 2017 Incrementum Gold Chart Book
      A Big Reference Chart Collection Our friends at Incrementum have created a special treat for gold aficionados, based on the 2017 “In Gold We Trust Report”. Not everybody has the time to read a 160 page report, even if it would be quite worthwhile to do so. As we always mention when it is published, it is a highly useful reference work, even if one doesn't get around to reading all of it (and selective reading is always possible, aided by the table of contents at the...
  • Precious Metals Supply and Demand
      Fundamental Developments The prices of the metals shot up last week, by $28 and $0.57.   Heavy metals became pricier last week, but we should point out that the stocks of gold and silver miners barely responded to this rally in the metals, which very often (not always, but a very large percentage of the time) is a sign that the rally is unlikely to continue or hold in the short term. [PT]   Last week, we said:   “One way to think of these moves is...

Support Acting Man

Top10BestPro
j9TJzzN

Austrian Theory and Investment

Archive

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com