High Court Holds Up Berlusconi's Tax Fraud Conviction

Many regard Silvio Berlusconi and his antics as an embarrassment for Italy, but we always liked the man's great entertainment value. Moreover, he has always been a thorn in the side of the eurocratic socialistic elites, as he never really got on board with their program. The program we're referring to is of course 'austerity for everyone except the State'.

Unfortunately for Berlusconi, he has left himself open to attack and it was clear that the moment he was no longer Italy's prime minister he would get into trouble with the courts. As long as he held the reins of power, he was able to hide behind laws that were custom-made especially for him and guaranteed him immunity from serious prosecution. As to the concrete cases he is involved in, there are so many that one is tempted to think that in view of so much smoke there must be a fire somewhere. On the other hand, it is also possible that his enemies were simply throwing a lot of cr*p on the wall to see if any of it would stick (not that we think him entirely innocent – very few men reaching such pinnacles of power are).

Anyway, we have not followed these cases in detail and can therefore not provide a well founded opinion on them. However, it is crystal clear that it was primarily his political stance that led to his downfall. The EU's leading lights detested him and held him responsible for worsening the crisis (and cutting their summer vacations short in the process). Indeed, it was Berlusconi's dispute with his economy minister Giulio Tremonti that set off the chain of events that culminated with the installation of the quintessential EU technocrat Mario Monti as Italy's prime minister.  Monti then promptly instituted the EU version of 'austerity', which consisted of 80% of tax hikes, 5% spending cuts and 15% financial repression measures (this is just a rough estimate for illustration purposes).

 

With the high court upholding Berlusconi's conviction, his political career is likely over, although he has little to worry about otherwise. However, his party rightly fears that losing its popular, if controversial, leader will be to its detriment and is fighting for his political survival. Moreover, the court has refused to order his expulsion from the senate pending a review. According to Bloomberg:

 

“Silvio Berlusconi’s conviction for tax fraud, upheld late yesterday by Italy’s top court, set up a Senate showdown over his potential expulsion from parliament.

The upper house’s committee for immunities is required to vote on whether to strip Berlusconi, a three-time premier and now a senator, of his seat. The debate, which may take weeks or months, threatens to stoke divisions in the ruling coalition, weakening Prime Minister Enrico Letta’s government.

“I am absolutely aware of the politically delicate moment,” Letta said today at a conference in Rome. “I hope that the collective interests prevail for the good of the country, the good of Italy, and not the partisan interests.”

The fight over Berlusconi’s fate moves to the political arena after the court, which confirmed his guilty verdict, left the sentence for his crime unresolved. Berlusconi was spared the immediate enforcement of a five-year ban on holding public office because the court said it required further judicial review. Berlusconi’s four-year jail sentence, which is temporarily suspended, is unlikely to land him in prison due to leniency guidelines.

“This legal matter could have significant political repercussions given that it is ultimately up to the Senate to vote on whether or not Berlusconi should be ineligible,”Wolfango Piccoli, an analyst with Teneo Intelligence, wrote today in a research report.

The Senate committee is required to consider the case due to a law passed in December under former Prime Minister Mario Monti. It will hold a preliminary vote prior to a final vote in the full Senate, which could be a secret ballot, the head of the committee, Dario Stefano, told Ansa news agency yesterday.

“I think the law must be applied, and from what I understand there is no margin for discretion,” Letta said.

The divide is deepening within the ruling coalition between lawmakers loyal to Berlusconi, 76, and those who, like Letta, have traditionally opposed him. Renato Brunetta, chief whip of Berlusconi’s People of Liberty party in the lower house, said the ruling put democracy in Italy in question, and vowed to rally around the ex-premier. Giuseppe Civati, a lawmaker with Letta’s Democratic Party, said it was time to plan “an exit strategy” from the alliance with Berlusconi.

Yesterday’s ruling was “completely groundless” and “irresponsible,” Berlusconi said in a video message. His party will “stay in the field” and seek a majority from Italians, the former premier said, without giving details.

 

(emphasis added)

A law introduced under Monti, which Letta thinks leaves no room for discretion? That's quite convenient. In the meantime Berlusconi's party colleagues have come up with a new idea: they are pushing for a pardon of the Cavaliere and are threatening to resign en masse unless they get their way.

 

“Former Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi’s party is preparing a push for a pardon of its leader’s tax-fraud conviction and will consider a mass resignation from parliament in protest.

“It was a strong possibility, but it will be in the hands of the chief whips,” Lucio Malan, a senator with Berlusconi’s People of Liberty party, said late yesterday about his colleagues’ discussion of a pardon request in a party meeting in Rome. Of a resignation, he said in an interview, “If we decide together to do it, then I’m ready.”

A group resignation by Berlusconi’s allies, who together represent the second-biggest bloc in the ruling parliamentary coalition, would bring down Prime Minister Enrico Letta’s government. President Giorgio Napolitano, who as head of state holds the power to grant pardons, said Aug. 1 in a statement that the justice system deserves trust and respect.”

 

(emphasis added)

This doesn't sound like president Napolitano is very eager to overrule the judges by means of a pardon. So the danger of the coalition government falling apart remains at the very least elevated, even though it cannot be said to be imminent (it is not imminent due to the court's decision to leave the expulsion issue to further 'review').

Incidentally, the markets were completely unperturbed; neither government bond yields nor the MIB reacted to the verdict or the threats. We conclude that in spite of the bluster, even Berlusconi's own party is probably beginning to accept that the Cavaliere's career will draw to a close. It's either that, or market participants are underestimating the potential for renewed political upheaval.

 


 

10yr. yield ItalyItaly's 10 year government bond yield – no reaction to the Berlusconi verdict – click to enlarge.

 


 

MIBThe MIB was likewise unperturbed – click to enlarge.

 


 

Preparing for Succession

One reason why the Cavaliere's troubles may no longer be considered a major problem is his age. He's 76 years old, so he's not exactly a spring chicken anymore, although he sure remains quite energetic for his age. As Der Spiegel reports, Berlusconi's plan A is to convince both Letta and Napolitano that letting him off the hook is in their own best interest – since no-one in Italy's political establishment wants early elections (Berlusconi himself on the other hand presumably wouldn't mind elections). He does however also have a plan B, namely to anoint his 47 year old daughter Marina as his successor. Incidentally she is 20 years older than Uncle Silvio's new girlfriend.

 

 

“Still, if worse comes to worst, Berlusconi already has a successor lined up — his daughter Marina. In recent days, Marina has been a part of all high-level party meetings, a noticeable change from the past. Indeed, Berlusconi used to be fond of saying that he didn't want his daughter to have to suffer as he has. Now, according to various Italian media outlets, Berlusconi has confided in a select few that his daughter should stand in the upcoming election. Berlusconi-owned "Il Giornale" has also predicted that Marina would perhaps throw her hat into the ring in her father's place.

Marina is Berlusconi's oldest daughter from his first marriage and has always been her father's favorite. Despite having dropped out of university, Marina was installed as the chief executive of her father's media company at the tender age of 30, making her — according to Forbes– the most influential woman in Italy.”

 

(emphasis added)

While we doubt that Marina will come close to her father in terms of entertainment value, this means there may be some sort of continuity in terms  of the underlying political philosophy (Berlusconi may also try to keep calling the shots from behind the scenes). Regardless of whether various eurocrats detested Berlusconi as a person, their real beef is probably with his political views. After all, Berlusconi is inter alia on record for saying that Italy should rather ditch the euro than becoming an economic protectorate of Brussels that remains mired in an economic downward spiral. He's the only mainstream EU politician heading something more substantial than a protest movement voicing such heretical thoughts.

 

The Nature of the Problem

The NYT meanwhile correctly notes that Italy has far worse problems than its flawed political leaders, but manages to at least partly misdiagnose the situation. We read there:

 

On the center-left, the problem is not a flawed leader, but no real leaders, and no real program either. Most of the best-known leaders are former Communists far too eager to prove their capitalist orthodoxy by unquestioning adherence to the ascetic doctrines favored by German bankers.

This has not made them popular with Italian voters. Nor has it helped the Italian economy emerge from what is now a double-dip recession. Unemployment is stuck around 12 percent, and growth has been minuscule for most of the past decade.

With such obvious weaknesses on both sides of the spectrum, the real winner of February’s elections was “none of the above.” The patched-together government that finally emerged in April is an ungainly coalition with few achievements to its credit so far.

What Italy desperately needs is wholesale political renewal producing capable leaders who can rally popular support for overdue structural economic reforms. Should such leaders emerge, their first responsibility would be to lead a credible challenge to the dead-end austerity demands of Italy’s European partners.”

 

(emphasis added)

The idea that Italy's former communists, now 'social democrats' (wolves in sheep's clothes, basically) want to prove their new-found 'capitalist orthodoxy' by adhering to the 'ascetic doctrines of German bankers' is laughable. Austerity as practiced in euro-land so far has absolutely nothing to do with 'capitalism' or 'capitalist orthodoxy'. Quite to the contrary, the policy has put pressure on the free market by imposing a plethora of new taxes while the size and scope of government continues to grow unabated. The data on spending and debt ratios speak for themselves: the program may be called 'austerity', thereby giving the false impression that it involves genuine cutbacks in government spending, but that is clearly disputed by the facts.

It is true that this particular program needs to be challenged and genuine economic reform needs to be implemented. Unfortunately the NYT fails to use its editorial to spell out what these reforms should consist of, but its focus on the misleading 'austerity' meme indicates to us that it holds that even more government spending is called for (as far as we know, all the prominent economics columnists working for the NYT hold this position). Just to make abundantly clear that Italy's government has not cut spending even by a single euro, here are the data:

 


 

EU government spendingItaly's government spending has reached a new record high in euro terms in 2012 – click to enlarge.

 


 

To be fair, the NYT editorial does mention 'structural reform', which is indeed what is required. Interestingly, it was an Italian, euro-land's current chief monetary bureaucrat, who has forwarded what has up to this point been one of the best ideas to emanate from EU institutions in this regard: in a recent ECB press conference, Mario Draghi stated that the crisis countries should use the breathing space provided by the calm in financial markets to cut both government spending and taxes, while continuing to implement economic reform. That is precisely what should be done. The biggest  problem in Europe is clearly that the burden of government has grown way too large. Keep in mind that both government spending and taxation burden the economy. The widespread belief that government spending must somehow be a good thing is based on the a number of misconceptions.

First and foremost there is the misguided idea that it is 'spending' that grows the economy. Secondly there is the failure to recognize that every red cent the government spends is one cent less the private sector has at its disposal. Thirdly it is overlooked that spending by the State, even if 'well intentioned', cannot properly account for opportunity costs and thus wastes scarce capital. Lastly, it creates competition for scarce resources with the genuine creators of wealth. Unfortunately there are only very few people in the European political landscape who actually understand these fundamental principles.

 

Addendum:

Here is a map of Europe as seen through Silvio Berlusconi's eyes:

 


 

europe-according-to-silvio-berlusconiEurope according to Berlusconi, by Yanko Tsvetkov

 


 

 

 

Charts by: BigCharts, Eurostat / Martin Masse


 

 
 

Dear readers, we are greatly honored by your readership and sincerely hope that our special mixture of entertainment and education continues to add a little value to your lives. As you can probably guess, our blog is not really a giant commercial enterprise, for that its readership is too exclusive and small. Nevertheless, running it involves not only time and effort, but also monetary costs. We are therefore starting another fundraising drive. You can help us reach our funding goal by either donating directly via Paypal or via Bitcoin.

 

Thank you for your support!

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

 
 

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • HelloThe Stock Market in Trouble - How Bad Can it Get?
      A Look at the Broader Market's Internals We have previously discussed the stock market's deteriorating internals, and in light of recent market weakness want to take a brief look at the broader market in the form if the NYSE Index (NYA). First it has to be noted that a majority of the stocks in the NYA are already in bearish trends. The chart below shows the NYA and the percentage of stocks above their 200 day and 50 day moving averages, which is 39.16% and 33.77% respectively. When...
  • Close-up view of a gold bar with shallow depth of field.Gold Stocks – Update on a Tricky Situation
      It's Never Easy... Readers may recall that in one of our recent updates on the gold sector – which we believe is at an interesting juncture that may at the very least provide a good trading opportunity – we presented the chart of the 1992-1993 low in order to illustrate how extremely tricky the sector can be in the vicinity of turning points. Specifically, the sector made every imaginable move in late 1992 to convince market participants that a durable rally was nigh impossible....
  • drop-water-gold-power-40854578Gold Stocks: A Playable Rally May Be Beginning as Junk Bonds Crater
      Gold Stocks Jump and Retrace 50% Last week we discussed the potential for a rally in the gold sector (see: “Gold Stocks at an Interesting Juncture” for details). Gold stocks jumped early in the week and then retraced almost precisely 50% of the initial move higher, in the process closing a gap that was left behind on Wednesday.   Image credit: dreamstime.com   Interestingly, for the first time in many months, there were three up days in a row prior to the...
  • gold rush copyA new Multi-Year High in Buying by Gold Sector Insiders
      Latest Data from INK Show A Huge Surge in Insider Buying As our friends at INK Research in Canada have pointed out to us, insiders at gold companies have made use of the recent sell-off in the sector to load up on shares to an extent not seen in many years.   Image source: bidness etc   The INK insider buy/sell indicator for gold stocks has peaked just one day after China's initial devaluation announcement at nearly 1,200%:   INK's gold insider sentiment...
  • oil_3136994bIs Crude Oil Close to a Low?
      Panicky Headlines Everybody knows that there is a never-ending glut in crude oil, right? Who knew about it a year ago? Not everybody, that much is certain. The problem with what everybody knows is of course that it is often not worth knowing.   Photo credit: Alamy   Today a friend pointed two articles out to us that have been published yesterday and today. Their headlines say it all. The Wall Street Journal writes “No End in Sight for Oil Glut” - and proceeds to...
  • panic-buttonThe Stock Market's Panic Potential
      The Odds Favor a “Warning Shot” Scenario - but there is a “But” As regular readers have probably noticed, we have upped the frequency of our “caution is advised” posts on the stock market in recent weeks in light of the market's increasingly deteriorating internals. Although one never knows when exactly such warning signs may begin to matter, it is always a good bet that they eventually will. Last week the market delivered a little wake-up call to the hitherto rather...
  • piggyReal Wealth and Phantom Wealth – Secular Boom and Bust
      The Things that Produce Real Wealth vs. Phantom Wealth Our friend Michael Pollaro, the keeper of long-term data on the true money supply and author at Forbes as well as occasionally a guest author on this site, recently sent us the following chart of a relationship he keeps a close eye on. It depicts the annual change rate in new orders for non-defense capital goods and compares this series to the Wilshire total market index.   Photo via...
  • JesusHuertaDeSotoJackson Hole – Meeting of the Physics Envy Brigade
      Planners Meet to Discuss the Impossible The Jackson Hole pow-wow takes place this weekend. A more revolting get-together of actual and armchair central planners (i.e., the advisors to the planners, many of whom see themselves as planners-in-waiting) could hardly be imagined. One has to wonder how much more damage they will be allowed to inflict before someone finally says “enough!”. The parlous state of the global economy and the series of booms and busts we have experienced over the...
  • post-mortemThe Stock Market After the Mini Crash
      A Post Mortem – the Influence of Black Box Systems Here is a brief update on the recent market action and what we think one should watch out for now. First of all, we already noted in our last market update that something about the recent “mini crash” was quite unusual. For one thing, it started to get serious in an options expiration week, which happens only rarely. One rather scary precedent is actually the 1987 crash: on that occasion the market declined sharply during expiration...
  • Godfrey-Bloom_1850647cGodfrey Bloom, Anti-Politician
      The Original Non-PC Politician Godfrey Bloom was UKIP's party whip for a long time, and for many years served as a member of the European parliament for UKIP. Ironically, although the party has solid electoral support in the UK, it has yet to make an inroad into Westminster due to the “first past the post” electoral system. It has always had a much greater representation in Strasbourg - at an institution it would prefer to abolish.   Godfrey Bloom: “The State is an...

Support Acting Man

Archive

Own physical gold and silver outside a bank

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com