A look at recent media reports on gold and the mechanics of the gold market, or:

How gold should not be analyzed.

Today we came across an article in the Wall Street Journal which asks, seemingly rhetorically, 'Is Gold the next Bubble?' Given that we are intellectually friendly toward gold, we actually hate to see such articles in the mainstream press. Luckily, the next article by the same author will be entitled 'The Dangers of Gold'. Phew.

 

Now, before continuing, the question asked in this article is actually posed the wrong way around. It should rather say 'are paper currencies in an anti-bubble?'. Gold is not a mere commodity after all, or even a mere investment asset. It is primarily money, or rather, it would be money if not for the State's imposition of legal tender. In short, in a true capitalistic free market oriented society, the market-selected money would most likely consist of gold. Moreover, the market in many ways treats gold as if it were money (more on that later).

As long as gold is not in general use as the medium of exchange, its 'money-ness' is so to speak in abeyance, but it still has all the characteristics of a currency competing with the fiat currencies of the world and it certainly continues to fulfill the 'store of value' function rather well.

 


 

Gold's dollar price over recent years: anyone keeping his savings in the yellow metal has certainly escaped the debauching of the central bank issued monies that has characterized this period. It is no coincidence that the money supply in nearly every nation on the planet has grown at extraordinary rates over the same time span – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

Meanwhile though, people invest in gold, or rather, exchange their paper or electronic government-issued tokens for it in the hope of preserving the purchasing power of their savings. We have no quibbles with the theory presented in the article – namely, that although the price of gold as expressed in various fiat monies has risen quite a bit over the past decade, it may well rise a lot more.

 

An intriguing chart is presented, comparing gold to previous bubbles, all of which it must be noted also were driven by massive expansions in money and credit.

 


 

This chart suggests that even after a substantial bull market, in the modern fiat money system, such bull markets tend to morph into bubble-like advances – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

A more substantial comparison was presented by Haver Analytics and Gluskin Sheff around the turn of the year:

 


 

Gold's advance from the 99/00 lows compared to some other bull markets – note that the starting points chosen for the markets concerned are a bit arbitrary. For instance, this includes only the Nikkei's advance during the 1980's, but the Nikkei had by that time risen by an even bigger percentage if 1969 is chosen as the starting point, when the Nikkei's value was at the same level as the DJIA's – around 1000 points (it peaked at over 38,000 points in 1989) – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

Naturally, even if the bull market in gold is fated to continue and deliver even bigger returns, it will likely be a bumpy ride with frequent corrections – some of which may be quite scary. Recall for instance that in 1987, the stock market suffered a roughly 40% 'correction', the bulk of which occurred in slightly more than one week.

In hindsight, it looks like an inconsequential bump in the road, but at the time when it happened, people were scared to death and thought the world was about to enter a new depression.

 


 

The crash of 1987 – at the time many people felt certain the bull market had ended – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

13 years later, the DJIA had risen about 540% from the 1987 crash low, which registers as a mere 'correction' on this long term chart – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

The weak economic conditions that are a hallmark of the secular contraction that began in the year 2000 have induced central banks to print more money than ever, while governments have been, and continue to be, on a deficit-spending spree that is the largest of the entire post WW2 era.

Therefore the potential for an even bigger gold price appreciation in coming years is significant. Contrary to the rate of change in the supply of paper money, gold's supply only rises by about 1,5% per year, and not all of that is added to the stockpile of monetary gold (i.e. gold held for investment purposes, which amounts to the same thing).

Furthermore, the final stage of a gold bull market tends to be driven by fear rather than greed – fear regarding the monetary system's continued viability, as faith in the state-issued money is lost. Clearly that fear was present when gold's price rose by about 200% in 1979 alone. The point is that fear-driven markets tend to make even bigger spikes than greed—driven ones.

 

 

Beware of flawed analyses

For reasons of not wanting the gold bull market get too crowded too quickly, we prefer seeing articles like the following one which originally appeared in Fortune: 'The coming gold bust'.

However, it is important for people to realize that some of the points made in this article are deeply flawed. Below is an excerpt that purports to demonstrate why the gold price can not only not rise further, but must soon come down again (note here, it may well correct and come down – but it won't be for any of the reasons Fortune has assembled in support of the argument).

 

  • Barclays Wealth in London predicts gold will fall to a fair value of $800 an ounce by 2012, as investors eventually dump it for riskier trades;
  • Société Générale, the French bank, in April 2009 predicted $800 gold by the end of 2010, though it has reversed its stance since then.
  • Analyst John Nadler of gold dealer Kitco predicts gold will fall to $900 in 2011.

Their reasoning is simple: investors are keeping prices high even as demand from non-investors is cratering.

Take gold jewelry, which accounts for more than half of the world's gold market. Demand there fell 8% in the fourth quarter of 2009 and is likely to continue to fall amid high prices that turn off shoppers. For example, in India, the largest gold buying country, high gold prices this week kept Indians from purchasing metal for the gold-buying festival of Akshaya Tritiya, which in turn drove down prices.

Then there's price pressure from the supply side. Higher gold prices mean miners work overtime. The supply of mine gold around the world jumped 7% last year to 2,572 tons-the second largest increase in history.

Gold bullion dealer Kitco says places like China and Russia will help boost the amount of gold from mining by 4% to 6% a year through 2014. Because it costs miners about $480 on average to extract an ounce of gold, they plow ahead when prices are high, eventually leading to an oversupply situation.

Gold at $1,200 also brings out the sellers and resellers. In 2009, scrap supply-all those gold pendants, necklaces and coins people have lying around-hit an all-time high of 1,700 tons. All those "we buy gold" signs, Internet advertisements and late night television commercials? Well, they're starting to work.

That scrap supply high is actually a 27% rise from 2008, according to Kitco. "So long as prices remain above $1,000-$1,100 we will continue to see a river of secondary gold actually starting to compete with mine production," says John Nadler, a Kitco analyst.

 

Unfortunately for gold bears, if this is the ammunition they rely on, they will be sorely disappointed. Neither jewelry demand nor mine supply nor scrap supply are of any lasting importance to the gold price. Just as these arguments are invalid as bearish arguments, they are invalid when they support a bullish stance as well (for instance, many bulls like to cite stagnant or falling mine supply as a bullish datum). The one argument that may make sense if we lived in a different era, would be the one about investors potentially preferring other investment avenues. Everything else is simply rubbish.

Gold can not to be analyzed as a commodity – it must be analyzed like a currency. It has an extremely high stock-to-flows ratio, as nearly all the gold ever mined in history still exists. Gold is not 'used up', which is one of the reasons why the market selected it as the money commodity.

Jewelry demand reached an all time high more than 10 years ago, in 1999 – just as gold hit a near 20-year price low. Ever since, jewelry demand (in terms of ounces) has been in decline. It hasn't kept gold from rising over 400% since the 1999 low. Jewelry demand is certainly price sensitive, so when investment demand for gold is low and the price falls, it tends to rise and vice versa.

However, it is impossible to spin a valid bearish argument relying on 'a decline in jewelry demand' or any other non-investment related demand. Consider that the above ground stock of gold is estimated to be 160,000 tons. With that kind of potential supply, what does it matter if mines produce 2,500 or 2,600 tons per annum, or whether jewelers buy 2,800 or 3,000 tons?

The answer is of course: it hardly matters at all. For the gold market, these are rounding errors. The same holds true for central bank buying and selling. While gold certainly received a psychological boost from India's purchase of 200 tons of IMF gold, the IMF could have just as well sold this amount on a sleepy morning at the LBMA (London Bullion Market Association), where some 600-700 tons trade every day. The amount is simply not all that relevant.

The two most important factors influencing the gold price are direct investment demand and so-called reservation demand. Of these terms only reservation demand requires perhaps an explanation – what is meant by this is the willingness of current holders of gold (naturally, with all the gold mined still in existence, someone owns it at all times – there is no unowned above-ground gold, except perhaps at the bottom of the ocean in sunken Spanish galleons – and that's not exactly 'above ground') to sell their gold at prevailing prices.

This reservation demand is not directly measurable, and is therefore simply left out of official supply – demand statistics. Also, we think that the so-called 'implied investment demand' used in analyses by e.g. the WGC (World Gold Council) or GFMS (Gold Fields Mineral Services) is a seriously flawed measure – it attempts to indirectly measure direct investment demand (respectively 'de-hoarding') by adding up mine supply and scrap, and deducting known jewelry and industrial demand, as well as industry de-hedging from that sum – the residual amount is thought to represent 'investment demand'.

It should be clear that in reality, total investment demand must be far higher. How else do we explain trading of 700 tons of gold every working day at the LBMA alone – when only about 2,500 tons are mined annually, and some 160,000 tons in potential supply are known to exist? Note here that not all of the 160,000 tons are theoretically or practically available for purchase – for instance, central banks are thought to hold some 31,000 tons in their vaults, and a certain amount of gold is used in industrial applications or remains in jewelry form, instead of as the bars and coins preferred by investors.

The upshot of all this is: one should ignore commodity-type approaches to analyzing gold. They will consistently lead to exactly the wrong conclusions during both bull and bear markets.

Our next article will look at how to actually best approach fundamental gold analysis and discuss other aspects of the gold market worth knowing. For today, we leave you with two near term charts:

 


 

Gold priced in US dollars – the recent uptrend appears intact. Net speculative futures positions have increased quite a bit, as they always do when gold trends higher (one more piece of evidence that investment demand is the main driver of the gold price), and while this is reason for caution when extremes are reached, it is not per se a negative as long as the technical condition of the market remains in bullish mode – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

The gold price in South African Rand vs. the share price of Harmony Gold, South Africa's third largest producer. One has risen, the other has languished – such a wide gap may represent a short term opportunity, as the earnings of S.A.'s producers are highly leveraged to the Rand gold price due to their relatively high production costs (however, one must of course keep in mind company-specific risks) – click on chart for higher resolution.

 


 

In the context of the final chart, we thought we'd bring you a recent humorous and apropos quote by famed fund manager Bill Fleckenstein, which a friend has mentioned to us:

 

“I keep waiting for the day when folks realize that if you invest in the shares of a gold mining company, you basically own a piece of "the money-creation machine." It's sort of like owning a central bank that isn't staffed by losers. “

 

We concur.

 

Charts by:

StockCharts.com, TFC commodity charts, Wall Street Journal, Haver Analytics / Gluskin Sheff, FactSet Research Systems, BigCharts.com

 


 
 

 
 

Dear Readers!

You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.

   

Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke

   
 

Your comment:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Most read in the last 20 days:

  • Yanking the Bank of Japan’s Chain
      Mathematical Certainties Based on the simple reflection that arithmetic is more than just an abstraction, we offer a modest observation.  The social safety nets of industrialized economies, including the United States, have frayed at the edges.  Soon the safety net’s fabric will snap. This recognition is not an opinion.  Rather, it’s a matter of basic arithmetic.  The economy cannot sustain the government obligations that have been piled up upon it over the last 70...
  • Prepare for Another Market Face Pounding
      “Better than Goldilocks” “Markets make opinions,” goes the old Wall Street adage.  Indeed, this sounds like a nifty thing to say.  But what does it really mean?   The bears discover Mrs. Locks in their bed and it seems they are less than happy. [PT]   Perhaps this means that after a long period of rising stocks prices otherwise intelligent people conceive of clever explanations for why the good times will carry on.  Moreover, if the market goes up for...
  • What Went Wrong With the 21st Century?
      Fools and Rascals   And it’s time, time, time And it’s time, time, time It’s time, time, time that you love And it’s time, time, time… - Tom  Waits   Tom Waits rasps about time   POITOU, FRANCE – “So how much did you make last night?” “We made about $15,000,” came the reply from our eldest son, a keen cryptocurrency investor. “Bitcoin briefly pierced the $3,500 mark – an all-time high. The market cap of the...
  • The Future of the Third World
      Decolonization The British Empire was the largest in history. At the end of World War II Britain had to start pulling out from its colonies. A major part of the reason was, ironically, the economic prosperity that had come through industrialization, massive improvements in transportation, and the advent of telecommunications, ethnic and religious respect, freedom of speech, and other liberties offered by the empire.   The colors represent the colonies of various nations...
  • Bitcoin Forked – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      A Fork in the Cryptographic Road So bitcoin forked. You did not know this. Well, if you’re saving in gold perhaps not. If you’re betting in the crypto-coin casino, you knew it, bet on it, and now we assume are happily diving into your greater quantity of dollars after the fork.   Bitcoin, daily – adding the current price of BCH (the new type of Bitcoin all holders of BTC can claim at a 1:1 ratio), the gain since the “fork” amounts to roughly $1,000 at the time we...
  • Seasonality: Will Patterns that Worked in the Past Also Work in the Future?
      Historians of the Future Every investor makes trading decisions based on what happened in the past – there is no other way. What really interests us is the future though. After all, what happens in the future ultimately determines investment success.   When in doubt, you can always try to reach the pasture...  In Human Action, Ludwig von Mises described stock market speculators as akin to “historians of the future”. This is without a doubt the most trenchant definition of...
  • Czar vs. Pope
      Vladimir the Great Sums Up Pope Francis the Fake Vladimir Putin has once again demonstrated why he is the most perceptive, farsighted, and for a politician, the most honest world leader to come around in quite a while.  If it had not been for his patient and wise statesmanship, the world may have already been embroiled in an all-encompassing global conflagration with the possibility of thermonuclear destruction.   Vladimir Putin is sizing up Pope Francis with his “good...
  • Bitcoin Has No Yield, but Gold Does – Precious Metals Supply and Demand Report
      Bitcoin and Credit Transactions Last week, we said:   It is commonly accepted to say the dollar is “printed”, but we can see from this line of thinking it is really borrowed. There is a real borrower on the other side of the transaction, and that borrower has powerful motivations to keep paying to service the debt. Bitcoin has no backing. Bitcoin is created out of thin air, the way people say of the dollar. The quantity of bitcoins created may be strictly limited by...
  • Is Historically Low Volatility About to Expand?
      Suspicion Asleep You have probably noticed it already: stock market volatility has recently all but disappeared. This raises an important question for every investor: Has the market established a permanent plateau of low volatility, or is the current period of low volatility just the calm before the storm?   All quiet on the VIX front... what can possibly happen? [PT] - click to enlarge.   When such questions regarding future market trends arise, it is often...
  • Why There Will Be No 11th Hour Debt Ceiling Deal
      Milestones in the Pursuit of Insolvency A new milestone on the American populaces’ collective pursuit of insolvency was reached this week. According to a report published on Tuesday by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, total U.S. household debt jumped to a new record high of $12.84 trillion during the second quarter. This included an increase of $552 billion from a year ago.   US consumer debt is making new all time highs – while this post GFC surge is actually...
  • Will They Haul Off Trump’s Statue, Too?
      Confused by Shadows POITOU, FRANCE – This week, we are talking about theperishable nature of gods. Yesterday, the city fathers of our hometown of Baltimore let it be known that it was time to toss out the old deities.   The Robert E. Lee and Thomas. J. “Stonewall” Jackson Monument in Baltimore, which the mayor inter alia wants to remove. Suddenly it has become fashionable to erase the memory of an important part of US history all over the country. By experience, this...
  • Bad Ideas About Money and Bitcoin
      How We Got Used to Fiat Money Most false or irrational ideas about money are not new. For example, take the idea that government can just fix the price of one monetary asset against another. Some people think that we can have a gold standard by such a decree today. This idea goes back at least as far as the Coinage Act of 1792, when the government fixed 371.25 grains of silver to the same value as 24.75 grains of gold, or a ratio of 15 to 1. This caused problems because the market...

Support Acting Man

j9TJzzN

Austrian Theory and Investment

Own physical gold and silver outside a bank

Archive

350x200

THE GOLD CARTEL: Government Intervention on Gold, the Mega Bubble in Paper and What This Means for Your Future

Realtime Charts

 

Gold in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Gold in EUR:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Silver in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

Platinum in USD:

[Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]

 


 

USD - Index:

[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]

 

 
Buy Silver Now!
 
Buy Gold Now!
 

Oilprice.com