France – a Zwangswirtschaft?
Zwangswirtschaft is the very apt German term Ludwig von Mises used to describe various forms of state capitalism, such as the economy of Nazi Germany. The literal translation is 'coerced economy' and as such it is a decisive step closer to a full-scale socialistic command economy than the severely hampered market economy (a milder form of state capitalism) that is in place in most of the so-called 'free world' today.
Francois Hollande is a typical colorless career bureaucrat-politician who never had a 'real job' in his whole life, this is to say, he never had to prove himself in the private sector. The cabinet put together by the perpetually astonished looking president (we strongly suspect that he is still astonished that he was actually elected) is of similar quality: it is almost a Soviet-style politbureau, with not a single senior minister who is not a career politician or bureaucrat (the two often go hand in hand in Europe).
German news magazine Der Spiegel, which is normally known to be sympathetic to the center-left, recently published a scathing article on the industrial dirigisme of Hollande's government the title of which leaves little to the imagination: “How Paris Is Killing French Industry”.
What prompted the magazine to take a closer look at France's economic policies was the case of ailing car maker Peugeot, which the president and his 'minister of industrial renewal' (talk about irony), Arnaud Montebourg have decided to micro-manage to death.
It is worth quoting the article at length, as the case demonstrates the attitude of the French government toward the private sector quite vividly:
“Well-meaning people can often be particularly dangerous. Take French President François Hollande and Minister of Industrial Renewal Arnaud Montebourg, for example. They want to rush to the aid of French automaker PSA, which has driven itself into a crisis with its Peugeot and Citroën brands. Representatives of the CGT trade union, such as Jean-Pierre Mercier, also want to help. "We will fight for our jobs and the livelihoods of our families," says Mercier.
The French government and the unions want to prevent Peugeot from closing its plant in Aulnay-sous-Blois, outside Paris, and slashing 8,000 jobs. But if politicians and labor leaders are successful, they will only make things worse. Perhaps they'll manage to save a few thousand jobs in France in the short term. But, by doing so, they will put the company's future into even greater jeopardy.
The company, which has been making cars since 1890, is fighting to survive. Sales have plummeted, and plants are not operating at anywhere close to capacity. PSA is currently losing €140 million ($173 million) a month.
For the 3,000 Peugeot workers in Aulnay-sous-Bois, their work ended temporarily at 10:30 p.m. on July 26. The plant was closed for five weeks, as it is every year for the summer vacation. But, this time, things were a little different. The commencement of the annual vacation period had a bitter aftertaste. Workers had just learned that the plant was to be permanently shut down in 2014.
President Hollande reacted immediately, saying that PSA's downsizing plans were "unacceptable" and had to be renegotiated. Minister Montebourg said that he had little faith in company management and speculated that perhaps the car company was merely playing the "imaginary invalid." He also said that he had a "real problem" with the company's strategy and the behavior of its main shareholder, the Peugeot family, which owns more than a quarter of its shares and received a substantial dividend last year.
Both CEO Philippe Varin and Supervisory Board Chairman Thierry Peugeot were called on the carpet, and the Peugeot family was forced to hear Montebourg deliver a lecture on patriotism. The company, the minister said, doesn't just belong to its shareholders, but also to "the history of France, a territory, a national idea."
The French state owns a share of Renault, the country's second-largest automaker, but not of Peugeot. Nevertheless, the government behaves as if Peugeot actually were a state-owned company. In this respect, it is demonstrating how matter-of-factly French politicians intervene in the management of major corporations.”
This, dear readers, is indeed the very essence of 'Zwangswirtschaft'. Nominally the means of production remain privately owned, such as is the case with Peugeot. However, the owners are no longer free to dispose of their assets as they see fit. A government bureau is telling them what they may or may not do. It is quite ironic that Montebourg puts nationalistic sentiments forward as the justification for the intervention. 'Peugeot doesn't just belong to its shareholders' because it is 'a national idea'. So what is Mountebank trying to tell us? That he's not only a socialist, but more precisely a national socialist?
He would probably bristle at the suggestion, but the difference between fascism and socialism is not as great as the enmity between these two camps would suggest. To both ideologies, the State is everything. The rest of us are only of interest inasmuch as we can be useful for serving the State's interests. Frequently this means that one ends up as cannon fodder.
However, even if one generously assumes, as the author of the Spiegel article does, that Hollande and Montebourg are merely misguided, 'well-meaning' and therefore 'particularly dangerous people', who genuinely believe that what they are doing will help workers, it does not alter the fact that their policies are likely to produce an outcome diametrically opposite to their stated goals.
They may well succeed in temporarily saving the jobs of a few thousand Peugeot workers with their intervention, but they are thereby endangering the jobs of many thousands more in the longer run.
Moreover, their dirigisme damages France's economy in other respects as well. By blithely disregarding property rights, they are sending a signal to all businessmen: you are no longer economically free. In fact, in light of Hollande's tax policies, the producers of France's wealth are apparently only free to serve as milk cows for the bloated bureaucracy.
Arnaud Montebourg, France's 'minster of industrial renewal'. He probably should be renamed France's industrial undertaker.
(Photo via flickr – Parti socialiste)
His perpetually surprised looking boss, who possibly missed a vocation as a stand-up comedian, Francois Hollande. The proverbial wolf in sheep's clothing, he is busy implementing long discredited economic policies. He likely owes his election mainly to the fact that he is not Nicolas Sarkozy.
(Photo via abaca)
The First Hundred Days
Gaspard Koenig, one of the many Frenchmen who have fled France for the more welcoming shores of Albion, has written an excellent essay on Hollande's first 100 days in office. Koenig not unreasonably concludes that “Hollande is the ultimate – and probably also terminal – embodiment of the European-style Welfare State”.
Many observers thought that a number of Hollande's election promises would eventually be discarded – that he could not possibly be the radical leftist he presented himself as. Generally, social democrats in Europe have moved ever closer to the political center in recent decades. Two pertinent examples are the UK's Tony Blair, and even more so Germany's Gerhard Schröder, whose free market oriented reforms of Germany's welfare state are nowadays regarded as the main reason for Germany's economic resurgence.
It is therefore not surprising that Hollande's candidacy and eventual election were initially greeted with some equanimity. However, it has now become clear that he really meant every word he said during his campaign. In Koenig's words:
“The policies decided during Hollande’s first 100 days all stem from a single rigorous point of doctrine: the political will can and should tame, and even replace, intrinsically evil markets.”
And so Hollande's government is implementing one policy after another inimical to the market economy – in the process demonstrating a degree of economic ignorance that is truly frightening. From price controls to lowering the retirement age to interventions in the affairs of large corporations as in the Peugeot case discussed above to vastly increasing the government's payroll, Hollande is apparently hell-bent on hastening France's economic demise.
All of this costs a lot of money, which the government doesn't really have – it has committed itself to reaching the deficit and public debt targets prescribed by the euro area's 'fiscal compact' after all. And so Hollande, like a modern-day Willie Sutton, goes to get the funds from 'where the money is' – the pockets of all those evil rich businessmen and producers of wealth, whose numbers are now dwindling in France at a rapid pace. Many have taken flight: today London is the 6th largest 'French' city, home to 400,000 Frenchmen who have fled Hollande's statist worker's paradise.
One doesn't need to be an anarcho-capitalist to recognize the overreach of a government that imposes a 'wealth tax' on people's assets and a 75% top marginal tax rate. No former King of France could have gotten away with such impositions. Heads would have rolled. Today a democratic head of State can feel quite secure while he shamelessly goes about picking the pockets of his most productive citizens – but they can still vote with their feet.
All of this makes it quite curious that bond investors are happily piling into France's sovereign debt. The extremely low interest rates in the euro area's 'core' are partly a result of weak economic activity and slow money supply growth, as well as the 'convertibility premium' Mario Draghi mentioned on occasion of the last ECB press conference (i.e., speculation on currency depreciation and appreciation after a putative break-up of the euro). In France's case it probably also reflects investors' approval of Hollande's deft confiscation of his citizens' wealth, but one can live off the accumulated wealth of the past only for so long.
The 2 year government bond-yield of France is close to zero – click for better resolution.
The 10 year yield is right at a new 270 year low – click for better resolution.
Obviously buyers of French government debt have no regrets thus far, but as the volatility in interest rates during 2010-2011 shows, market confidence is probably far more fragile than it currently appears.
The French government still must confront a €33 billion hole in its budget, and this happens at a time when France's economy is in contraction and its most productive citizens are sorely tempted to either pack up and leave or simply 'go Galt'. Moreover, France's banks hold assets worth over 400% of the country's GDP, and have the by far biggest exposure to debt in Italy, Spain, Portugal and Greece among banks in the euro area's 'core'.
Investors buying French debt at today's paltry yields have a remarkable ability to suspend disbelief. Stock market investors seem less prone to succumbing to illusions these days. Although the CAC 40 in Paris is well off the lows made in 2011 and earlier this year, the long term chart of the index continues to look bearish, as every rebound since the 2009 crash low looks corrective. In fact, the French stock market has never regained the peak it made 12 years ago at the height of the tech mania.
A textbook secular bear market: the CAC 40 Index in Paris – click for better resolution.
Charts by: BigCharts
It is that time of the year again – our semi-annual funding drive begins today. Give us a little hand in offsetting the costs of running this blog, as advertising revenue alone is insufficient. You can help us reach our modest funding goal by donating either via paypal or bitcoin. Those of you who have made a ton of money based on some of the things we have said in these pages (we actually made a few good calls lately!), please feel free to up your donations accordingly (we are sorry if you have followed one of our bad calls. This is of course your own fault). Other than that, we can only repeat that donations to this site are apt to secure many benefits. These range from sound sleep, to children including you in their songs, to the potential of obtaining privileges in the afterlife (the latter cannot be guaranteed, but it seems highly likely). As always, we are greatly honored by your readership and hope that our special mixture of entertainment and education is adding a little value to your life!
Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke
9 Responses to “Francois Hollande – Moving France Toward A Command Economy”
Most read in the last 20 days:
- Ganging Up on Gold
So Far a Normal Correction In last week's update on the gold sector, we mentioned that there was a lot of negative sentiment detectable on an anecdotal basis. From a positioning perspective only the commitments of traders still appeared a bit stretched though, while from a technical perspective we felt that a pullback to the 200-day moving average in both gold and gold stocks shouldn't be regarded as anything but a normal - and in this case actually long overdue -...
- Gold Sector Correction – Where Do Things Stand?
Sentiment and Positioning When we last discussed the gold sector correction (which had only just begun at the time), we mentioned we would update sentiment and positioning data on occasion. For a while, not much changed in these indicators, but as one would expect, last week's sharp sell-off did in fact move the needle a bit. Gold - just as nice to look at as it always is, but slightly cheaper since last week. Photo via The Times Of India The commitments of...
- Australian property bubble on a scale like no other
Australian property bubble on a scale like no other Yesterday Citi produced a new index which pinned the Australian property bubble at 16 year highs: Bubble trouble. Whether we label them bubbles, the Australian economy has experienced a series of developments that potentially could have the economy lurching from boom to bust and back. In recent years these have included: the record run up in commodity prices and subsequent correction; the associated...
- A Looming Banking Crisis – Is a Perfect Storm About to Hit?
Andy Duncan Interviews Claudio Grass Andy Duncan of FinLingo.com has interviewed our friend Claudio Grass, managing director of Global Gold in Switzerland. Below is a transcript excerpting the main parts of the first section of the interview on the problems in the European banking system and what measures might be taken if push were to come to shove. Andy Duncan of FinLingo.com (left) and Claudio Grass of Global Gold (right) Andy Duncan: How do you see the...
- Pope Francis: Traitor to Western Civilization
Disqualified There has been no greater advocate of mass Muslim migration into Europe than the purported head of the Catholic Church, Pope Francis. At a recent conference, he urged that “asylum seekers” be accepted, “through the acts of mercy that promote their integration into the European context and beyond.”* Before we let Antonius continue with his refreshingly politically incorrect disquisition, we want to remind readers of two previous articles that have...
- Bubble Dissection
The Long Term Outlook for the Asset Bubble Due to strong internals, John Hussman has given the stock market rally since the February low the benefit of the doubt for a while. Lately he has returned to issuing warnings about the market's potential to deliver a big negative surprise once it runs out of greater fools. In his weekly market missive published on Monday (entitled “Sizing Up the Bubble” - we highly recommend reading it), he presents inter alia the following eye-popping...
- US Stock Market - a Spanking May be on its Way
Iffy Looking Charts The stock market has held up quite well this year in the face of numerous developments that are usually regarded as negative (from declining earnings, to the Brexit, to a US presidential election that leaves a lot to be desired, to put it mildly). Of course, the market is never driven by the news – it is exactly the other way around. It is the market that actually writes the news. It may finally be time for a spanking though. Time for some old-fashioned...
- Prepare for the Unthinkable
Red Ink Growth and profits mask a variety of problems. They hide business inefficiencies and the money suck of corporate adminis-trivia. They also conceal unproductive staff. The final career leap But most of all growth and profits obscure the extreme value subtracting forces of bloated management teams. During good times it is unclear what these smug fellows do. During bad times it is lucidly clear that most of them ain’t worth a darn. When the...
- Doomed to Failure
Larded Up and Larded Over We’ve been waiting for the U.S. economy to reach escape velocity for the last six years. What we mean is we’ve been waiting for the economy to finally become self-stimulating and no longer require monetary or fiscal stimulus to keep it from stalling out. Unfortunately, this may not be possible the way things are going. As Milton Jones once revealed: “A month before he died, my grandfather covered his back in lard. After that, he went...
- Meet Your New Stimulus Allocation Czar
March Towards Midnight The march towards midnight is both stirring and foreboding. Like a death row inmate sitting down to savor his last meal, a grim excitement greets the reality of impending doom. Thoughts of imminent mortality haunt each bite. Tic-toc, tic-toc... As far as the economy’s concerned, there’s no stopping its march towards midnight. The witching hour’s rapidly approaching. We intend to savor each moment and make the best of...
- Are the Deep State’s Drones Coming for You?
What’s Aleppo? Look out kid Don’t matter what you did Walk on your tip toes Don’t try "No Doz" Better stay away from those That carry around a fire hose Keep a clean nose Watch the plain clothes You don’t need a weather man To know which way the wind blows – “Subterranean Homesick Blues,” Bob Dylan The entrance to Baghdad's “Green Zone”. Photo credit: Karim Kadim / AP DELRAY BEACH, Florida – Biggest foreign policy blunder...
- Interview with Doug Casey
Natalie Vein of BFI speaks with Doug Casey Our friend Natalie Vein recently had the opportunity to conduct an extensive interview with Doug Casey for BFI, the parent company of Global Gold. Based on his decades-long experience in investing and his many travels, he shares his views on the state of the world economy, his outlook on critical political developments in the US and in Europe, as well as his investment insights and his approach to gold, as part of a viable strategy for...