The Economics of Large Pools of Property Assets
For spot REOs [REO = 'real estate owned', the euphemism for properties repossessed in foreclosures, ed.], which are primarily all single family, condos and some 1-4 family units, the pecking order of potential buyers could not be simpler:
- Owner occupants.
- Small investors who own no more than a handful of units.
- Large investors who own multiple units in one market.
- Large investors who own multiple units in multiple markets.
- Mega bulk investors.
For some strange reason, our government is comtemplating bypassing all the more suitable buyers listed above in favor of the worst buyers possible. There can be no explanation for this aside from stupidity and/or corruption.
The logic behind this is simple. Economies of scale so to speak tend to work in reverse when it comes to spot REOs. At each level of the pecking order, the expenses one incurs are higher rather than lower. For example, an owner occupant or small investor may purchase a property that requires minor repairs and budget nothing but 'sweat equity' for these items. A large local investor may have a crew or an inexpensive contractor for these repairs. A mega bulk investor has to contract a local manager, who then gives the job to sub-contractors to have the work performed.
Spot REOs are in various places all over the map. The houses in the best locations are usually gobbled up at top prices immediately. The second tier ones may require a few rounds of price reductions and re-appraisals to move them off the books. Then there are the junk units that may not be marketable at all for one reason or another. When an asset manager is burdened with hundreds of properties to sell, the junk properties usually are set aside, resulting in a growing 'dead pool' as time passes.
If there are to be bulk sales, these are certainly properties that should be included in the pools. However, for a mega bulk buyer, there may be no discount that is steep enough to justify buying them. For example, if a bulk investor buys 1,000 apartment units in five completely run down projects, then those are five projects where investors can hire a team for each site and bring the respective property back to the standards associated with its highest and best use. If there are 1,000 different locations spread all over a region, then we are looking at 1,000 different projects – logisitically an entirely different proposition. These properties may be located in, say, Atlanta and may only have a price tag of $20-30 million, certainly not low enough to whet the appetite of a big investor, not to mention a mega bulk investor.
The GSEs reportedly carry an inventory of approximately 200,000 in REOs on their books. If those were divided into $1 billion pools at an average price of $100,000 per property, that would require 20 pools consisting of 10,000 properties per pool. Unlike the purchase of loans or securities, buying such a pool involves taking ownership of properties and assuming liabilities that one may be eager to assume.
Do you have any idea what it takes to assemble a pool of 10,000 REOs and prepare the required due diligence packages? If the GSEs were able to miraculously conduct one of these billion dollar bulk sales every quarter, it would still take 5 years to liquidate their existing REO inventory.
An Alternative Proposal to Mega Bulk Sales
Location, location, location. The metro areas that have somewhat stabilized do not need mega bulk sales in any form. The metro areas that have excessive REO inventories usually have large supply/demand imbalances where a bulk sale may tend to exacerbate the problems. Just imagine the poor homeowners struggling with an already underwater mortgage, only to find out that their newest neighbor is some hedge fund who bought the same house at a discount of 30%-40% – or most likely more. Imagine the poor little investor with negative cash flow trying to compete against the hedge fund for a tenant in such a down market.
How much of a discount is required in order for a mega bulk buyer to offset all the inefficiencies associated with a bulk purchase and still generate a reasonable internal rate of return? It is a near certainty that mega bulk buyers would demand a very big discount, combined with some sort of below market financing and some form of indemnification.
Here are a few alternatives that illustrate how incredibly stupid the mega bulk sales idea is. For the purpose of this illustration, I am going to make the assumption that a bulk buyer is going purchase at 70% of the most recent appraisal and is happy with 70% financing at the prevailing rates available to an owner occupant. This assumption is generously conservative – in reality I cannot picture any mega bulk buyer willing to pay so much for the GSE inventory.
Alternative 1, target the owner users:
Sales price set at the most recent appraisal.
Nothing down financing at prevailing rates for owner users.
No points, no fees, no closing costs. They are all factored into the loan.
A minimum credit score of, say, 650.
Buyer must show they have been paying rent for the past six months at or above the project PITI (principal, interest, tax and insurance).
This alternative would open the door to a great many buyers. They are not going to hurt the market because they are paying full price. They are not going to hurt the other properties listed for sale, because they would not be buyers if a down payment were required. They would have already demonstrated that they can afford the monthly payment in the form of rent. As owners, they would most likely improve the property, which a tenant would not do.
In comparison to a bulk sale, an owner user is paying 30% more, offering the GSE a big cushion on top of all the aforementioned benefits.
Alterative 2, target small investors:
Sales price set at the most recent appraisal.
20% down payment. Financing at prevailing rates for owner users.
No qualifications needed, the downpayment is the security.
This alternative would open the door to all the local investors that may currently have a tough time with financing. Based on the Federal Reserve's analysis, these properties are supposed to generate an 8% cap rate or even better return. With a 20% down payment, the property should generate a copious cash flow for the buyer. These buyers are not going to hurt the market because they would be paying full price. They would be more likely to take care of the property with the pride of ownership, much better than what can be expected of an impersonal hedge fund owner who is at several removes via a few layers of asset and property management staff.
In comparison to a bulk sale, a small investor is paying 30% more and is putting up 20% cash.
There are numerous other ideas to correctly market REOs but just the two alternatives mentioned above should put a big dent in any inventory. If the properties are not selling at a satisfactory pace, there are many follow up steps that could be implemented. I will discuss those in a future post.
In conclusion, any mega bulk sales by the GSEs would certainly be a big loss for taxpayers. If the mega bulk buyers think they are going to rip off the country the same way their predecessors did during the RTC giveaway, they may be in for a big surprise. They may eventually find themselves holding cans of worms all over the most undesirable markets.
As for the real estate market, I have no idea what mega bulks would do to the already depressed metro areas. They could prove to be very destabilizing. Maybe they would be the last straw that breaks the camel's back.
You may have noticed that our so-called “semiannual” funding drive, which started sometime in the summer if memory serves, has seamlessly segued into the winter. In fact, the year is almost over! We assure you this is not merely evidence of our chutzpa; rather, it is indicative of the fact that ad income still needs to be supplemented in order to support upkeep of the site. Naturally, the traditional benefits that can be spontaneously triggered by donations to this site remain operative regardless of the season - ranging from a boost to general well-being/happiness (inter alia featuring improved sleep & appetite), children including you in their songs, up to the likely allotment of privileges in the afterlife, etc., etc., but the Christmas season is probably an especially propitious time to cross our palms with silver. A special thank you to all readers who have already chipped in, your generosity is greatly appreciated. Regardless of that, we are honored by everybody's readership and hope we have managed to add a little value to your life.
Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke
Most read in the last 20 days:
- Gold - Ready to Spring Another Surprise
Sentiment Extremes Below is an update of a number of interesting data points related to the gold market. Whether “interesting” will become “meaningful” remains to be seen, as most of gold's fundamental drivers aren't yet bullishly aligned. One must keep in mind though that gold is very sensitive with respect to anticipating future developments in market liquidity and the reaction these will elicit from central banks. Often this involves very long lead times. Blackbeard's...
- Modi’s Great Leap Forward
India’s Currency Ban – Part VIII India’s Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, announced on 8th November 2016 that Rs 500 (~$7.50) and Rs 1,000 (~$15) banknotes would no longer be legal tender. Linked are Part-I, Part-II, Part-III, Part-IV, Part-V, Part-VI and Part-VII, which provide updates on the demonetization saga and how Modi is acting as a catalyst to hasten the rapid degradation of India and what remains of its institutions. India’s Pride and Joy Indians are...
- Global Recession and Other Visions for 2017
Conjuring Up Visions Today’s a day for considering new hopes, new dreams, and new hallucinations. The New Year is here, after all. Now is the time to turn over a new leaf and start afresh. Naturally, 2017 will be the year you get exactly what’s coming to you. Both good and bad. But what else will happen? Image of a recently discarded vision... Image by Michael Del Mundo Here we begin by closing our eyes and slowing our breath. We let our mind...
- The Great El Monte Public Pension Swindle
Nowhere City California There are places in Southern California where, although the sun always shines, they haven’t seen a ray of light for over 50-years. There’s a no man’s land of urban blight along Interstate 10, from East Los Angeles through the San Gabriel Valley, where cities you’ve never heard of and would never go to, are jumbled together like shipping containers on Terminal Island. El Monte, California, is one of those places. Advice dispensed on Interstate...
- A Trade Deal Trump Cannot Improve
Worst in Class BALTIMORE – People can believe whatever they want. But sooner or later, real life intervenes. We just like to see the looks on their faces when it does. By that measure, 2017 may be our best year ever. Rarely have so many people believed so many impossible things. Alice laughed. "There's no use trying," she said: "one can't believe impossible things." "I daresay you haven't had much practice," said the Queen. "When I was your age, I always did it for...
- Pope Francis Now International Monetary Guru
Neo-Marxist Pope Francis Argues for Global Central Bank As the new year dawns, it seems the current occupant of St. Peter’s Chair will take on a new function which is outside the purview of the office that the Divine Founder of his institution had clearly mandated. Neo-Papist transmogrification. We highly recommend the economic thought of one of Francis' storied predecessors, John Paul II, which we have written about on previous occasions. In “A Tale of Two Popes” and...
- Trump’s Trade Catastrophe?
“Trade Cheaters” It is worse than “voodoo economics,” says former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers. It is the “economic equivalent of creationism.” Wait a minute - Larry Summers is wrong about almost everything. Could he be right about this? Larry Summers, the man who is usually wrong about almost everything. As we have always argued, the economy is much safer when he sleeps, so his tendency to fall asleep on all sorts of occasions should definitely be welcomed....
- Where’s the Outrage?
Blind to Crony Socialism Whenever a failed CEO is fired with a cushy payoff, the outrage is swift and voluminous. The liberal press usually misrepresents this as a hypocritical “jobs for the boys” program within the capitalist class. In reality, the payoffs are almost always contractual obligations, often for deferred compensation, that the companies vigorously try to avoid. Believe me. I’ve been on both sides of this kind of dispute (except, of course, for the “failed”...
- Money Creation and the Boom-Bust Cycle
A Difference of Opinions In his various writings, Murray Rothbard argued that in a free market economy that operates on a gold standard, the creation of credit that is not fully backed up by gold (fractional-reserve banking) sets in motion the menace of the boom-bust cycle. In his The Case for 100 Percent Gold Dollar Rothbard wrote: I therefore advocate as the soundest monetary system and the only one fully compatible with the free market and with the absence of force or fraud...
- Silver’s Got Fundamentals - Precious Metals Supply-Demand Report
Supply-Demand Fundamentals Improve Noticeably Last week was another short week, due to the New Year holiday. We look forward to getting back to our regularly scheduled market action. Photo via thedailycoin.org The prices of both metals moved up again this week. Something very noticeable is occurring in the supply and demand fundamentals. We will give an update on that, but first, here’s the graph of the metals’ prices. Prices of gold and silver...
- Trump’s Plan to Close the Trade Deficit with China
Rags to Riches Jack Ma is an amiable fellow. Back in 1994, while visiting the United States he decided to give that newfangled internet thing a whirl. At a moment of peak inspiration, he executed his first search engine request by typing in the word beer. Jack Ma, founder and CEO of Alibaba, China's largest e-commerce firm. Once he was a school teacher, but it turned out that he had enormous entrepreneurial talent and that the world of wheelers, dealers, movers and...
- Side Notes, January 14 - Red Flags Over Goldman Sachs
Red Flags Over Goldman Sachs Just to prove that I am an even-handed insulter, here is a rant about my former employer, Goldman Sachs. The scandal at 1MDB, the Malaysian sovereign wealth fund from which it appears that billions were stolen by politicians all the way up to the Prime Minister, continues to unfold. The main players in the 1MDB scandal. Irony alert: apparently money siphoned off from 1MDB was used to inter alia finance Martin Scorcese's movie “The Wolf of...