Euro Area Credit Market Charts
Further below is our customary collection of CDS prices, bond yields, euro basis swaps and several other charts. Both charts and price scales are color coded (readers should keep the different scales in mind when assessing 4-in-1 charts). Prices are as of Friday's close.
Friday saw some improvement in Spain's bond yields, and a slight rise in Italy's. These are currently probably the most important government bond yields in the world. CDS on Spain and Italy have come in a bit as well, but at 419 and 542 basis points respectively remain uncomfortably elevated. Yields on the bonds of the euro area's 'AAA club' generally improved strongly last week, in spite of the rising probability of ratings downgrades (see Austrian yields below as an example, French 10 year yields also declined by about 30 basis points last week). Euro basis swaps improved strongly.
We note that the EU's ban on 'naked' CDS trading has had exactly zero effect on CDS prices – in other words, the ban has predictably failed to bring about the desired result. It may well have exacerbated selling in sovereign bonds however, as those can still be shorted – which a few fund managers appear to have indeed done.
Greece & David Einhorn
The IMF's recent negative assessment of Greece's progress in meeting its fiscal targets has not gone unnoticed in the markets. 5 year CDS on Greece trade now at an incredible 14,395 basis points. We have never seen anything like this. It costs now nearly 44% more to insure Greek government debt against default than the face value of said debt amounts to. In other words, it implies a negative recovery, which is theoretically impossible. This may appear to make no sense until one considers that e.g. the yield on the one year note currently stands at around 330%. So for a buyer of the one year note it still makes sense to pay up for insurance to at least limit potential losses in case of a hard default , or putting it differently, this trade amounts to an arbitrage of negative basis (we can't come up with a better explanation at this point – if someone can, please enlighten us. We know that sometimes CDS involving special bilateral agreements w.r.t. upfront payments trade above 10,000 bips). This arbitrage is not without risk, as coupons are usually paid semi-annually, while payments on CDS must be made quarterly.
As far as the implied default probability goes, try: 'double-plus-100%-certain'. Back in June, when CDS on Greece rose to a 'mere' 3,045 basis points, a World Bank report on Greece indicated that this implied a 91% default probability.
Among notable recent events surrounding Greek debt, David Einhorn's Greenlight Funds have cashed out of many sovereign CDS holdings following the decision to make the Greek debt exchange a 'voluntary' event, which appeared specifically designed to protect various CDS writing banks from having to pay up, while keeping up the charade that euro are nations simply don't default.
However, Einhorn evidently remains quite convinced that Greece will eventually default, since he has shorted its bonds instead. This trade has the added advantage of removing the counterparty risk of CDS writers.
As Bloomberg reports, quoting from a (slightly dated) Einhorn letter to investors in the Greenlight fund:
„Greenlight revealed some of its thinking in a July 7 investor letter that cites “The Treachery of Images,” a by the Belgian surrealist René Magritte, in discussing European efforts to avoid a Greek debt default.
The letter touched on two risks tied to credit swaps on European sovereign debt, including regulators’ attempts to fashion a Greek bailout in a way that prevented the contracts from paying out. The second risk was the possibility that banks that wrote billions of dollars in credit swaps on sovereign debt might not be able to make good on their obligations should a country such as actually default.
Greenlight, citing French President in particular, noted that regulators were determined to prevent the Greek bailout from being classified as a “credit event,” which would trigger a payout to swap holders. Stating that “it is very odd to hear a political leader use such technical jargon,” Greenlight then asks in the letter “Why would Mr. Sarkozy do this?”
The letter raises the possibility that French banks have “enormous exposure” to sovereign-credit events. That’s because banking regulations define sovereign credits as risk free, allowing banks to take on as much sovereign-credit risk as they wanted, perhaps by issuing credit swaps, without having to set aside any capital.
“Under such a structure, selling short CDS protection is akin to free money for the banks,” Greenlight says in the letter. “No one knows just how much aggregate exposure to sovereign debt and CDS is hidden in the banking system, and no one is itching to find out.”
In late October, the European Union reached an agreement where banks would write down their holdings of Greek bonds by 50 percent. The International Swaps and Derivatives Association’s chief lawyer said because the deal is considered voluntary, it won’t require firms that sold credit protection on Greece to pay buyers of the swaps.
In describing the potential for this sort of outcome back in July, Greenlight recalled that Magritte’s pipe painting includes a caption that translates to “This is not a pipe.” Magritte proved the image was not a pipe by telling doubters, ‘Just try to fill it with tobacco’.
“As Magritte might say, ‘This is not a default’,” Greenlight wrote. “Just try to collect on your credit default swaps.”
The Treachery of Images
Try to fill it with tobacco and you'll notice it is not a pipe – it is just an image.
(Painting by René Magritte)
Considering the Magrittian nature of CDS on Greece, someone sure seems to think that in spite of all the contortions, these contracts will pay out.
5 year CDS on Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain. At 14,395 basis points, Greece is setting records once again – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on France, Belgium, Ireland and Japan – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on Bulgaria, Hungary, Croatia and Austria – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on Latvia, Lithuania, Slovenia and Slovakia – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on Romania, Poland, Lithuania and Estonia – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, Morocco and Turkey – click chart for better resolution.
Three month, one year, three year and five year euro basis swaps – there was a big bounce in those, and it is probably no coincidence that gold rallied concurrently – click chart for better resolution.
Our proprietary unweighted index of 5 year CDS on eight major European banks (BBVA, Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena, Societe Generale, BNP Paribas, Deutsche Bank, UBS, Intesa Sanpaolo and Unicredito) – pulling back a little. This index tends to move in the opposite direction of the euro basis swaps most of the time; in that sense we note that there was recently a notable divergence, in that the index failed to reach its previous high even though euro basis swaps revisited their earlier extreme – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on two Austrian banks (Erstebank and Raiffeisen), indexed – to get the value in basis points divide the index values by the divisors in the legend. These banks are greatly exposed to the CEE region and have received a painful blow from Viktor Orban's government in Hungary, which unilaterally re-denominated CHF mortages into forint – click chart for better resolution.
10 year government bond yields of Italy, Greece, Portugal and Spain – Spain's yields are trending down, Italy's can only be said to have dipped slightly (in fact, on Friday they bounced again, if only by 2 basis points) – click chart for better resolution.
10 year government bond yield of Austria, the 9 year government bond yield of Ireland, UK Gilts and the Greek 2 year note. A new low in gilt yields and both Austrian and Irish yields keep improving, the former noticeably so – click chart for better resolution.
5 year CDS on the debt of Australia's 'Big Four' banks – a small dip – click chart for better resolution.
The ECB's balance sheet. For those who may have missed this chart last week: the size of the ECB's balance sheet as of last week in € billion. Since the low point in April (incidentally this was around the time Western stock markets topped out), some €500 billion have been added, growing the balance sheet by more than 25% – click chart for better resolution.
Nevertheless, true money supply growth stood at only 1.8% year-on-year at the end of October, whereby currency in circulation grew by 6.5% and sight deposits by a mere 0.8%. This is – so far – in stark contrast to the big post 2008 crisis jump in money supply growth. Note however in this context that there was a notable lag between ECB balance sheet expansion (which began in late 2007) to the jump in money supply growth back then, and we can not yet judge the effect the most recently announced easing measures will have on money supply growth.
ISDA discusses Euro Breakup
It sure looks like no-one is believing the spin-meisters in Brussels anymore. The latest agency to give some thought to the consequences of a euro breakup is ISDA (International Swaps and Derivatives Association), the same pliable organization that has decided to follow the eurocracy's reasoning on the Greek 'non-credit event' that somehow stipulates that creditors can lose 50% of their investment while they can simultaneously take their hedges and use them as wall-paper (and Greece is not even happy with 50%, but wants to reduce the net present value of the new bonds further by offering a lower coupon, effectively demanding a 75% haircut).
Still, it seems to have dawned on ISDA's members that trusting the promises that emerge from various emergency summits in the euro area may turn out to be a mug's game. This is a reasonable assessment – it is better to be prepared and sorry than to be not prepared and be really sorry.
“Professionals in the $708 trillion global swaps market have been pondering how their contracts could be affected by a partial or full dissolution of the euro, prompting the industry's trade body to start advising swap users how to plan for such potential scenarios.
The International Swaps and Derivatives Association sent a memo to members Thursday saying it will hold a webcast next week to discuss "what would happen to euro-denominated derivatives contracts if one or more countries were to leave the euro-zone and establish an alternative currency."
In the memo, seen by Dow Jones Newswires, the association said it believed a euro breakup was unlikely but added it had been contacted by many of its members who are "already making contingency plans" and have been "instructed by their supervisors to report on their preparations." Members have asked ISDA to pay a role in their planning. The trade body, which plays a crucial role in determining market standards for swap contracts, didn't respond to requests for comment Friday.
But in the memo, the association said it had been consulting with its counsel "for some time" to contemplate the implications of a possible euro breakup, and how the swaps industry could prepare. ISDA's webcast will be held on Dec. 21 at 3pm London time, and is closed to the press and non-members of the association.
One possible response to a euro-zone exit is to have an industry protocol that would switch swaps, those that either require payment in the common currency or delivery of euros, to one or more new currencies, lawyers said Friday. ISDA used such a protocol in 1998 to convert swaps requiring payment in legacy currencies, or referencing them to the euro at fixed conversion rates.
"Protocols are an efficient way to agree large numbers of contracts with several people very quickly," said Matthew Magidson, chair of the derivatives practice at Lowenstein Sandler. "I'd imagine there very well could be a market protocol so there is an orderly and agreed-upon way to deal with a potential disappearance of the euro," said another lawyer.
One of the biggest challenges is preparing for a possible event that could happen in so many different ways, with varying outcomes. A third lawyer said the protocol for transitioning swap contracts to the euro was devised several months after politicians had decided on a plan to bring about the euro, whereas in this case there is no such plan.
It's not clear if there could be one or more individual sovereigns looking to exit, or a wholesale breakup eliminating the euro entirely, or even a north-south divide in Europe's usage of the common currency.
Nor is it clear whether any exit would be orderly and consensually agreed upon under a treaty, or unilaterally decided by the departing member. The U.K. opted out of the euro currency, for example, but is still part of the European Union, and committed to certain movement of people, goods and capital among member states.
With so much uncertainty, the industry can only brainstorm what the possible issues could be, lawyers said. Chief among these is how contracts would be affected by their governing jurisdictions–most falling under U.K. or New York law–and whether payments could be made in any new currency if a party to a trade was domiciled in a departing member state.”
Sounds like it will be an interesting discussion – transitioning to a new state of affairs for which 'there is no plan'.
Voting One's Book
In other news, some holders of CDS have just alleged that the ISDA committee that decides on what constitutes a credit event is riddled with bias, i.e. they claim it is voting its own book. This happened in connection with the recent keeling over of SEAT Pagine Gialle, an Italian company. Greece merits a mention as well.
“Senior credit traders have heavily criticised the committee that rules on credit default swap triggers, accusing rival firms of voting based on their trading positions rather than on legal merits.
The International Swaps and Derivatives Association strongly rejected the allegations, which stem from a split vote concerning whether or not a credit event had occurred with respect to Italian firm SEAT Pagine Gialle on November 28. But the derivatives trade body admitted it was in the process of bolstering standards to ensure dealers cannot "vote their books".
The critical remarks will come as blow to ISDA's EMEA Credit Derivatives Determination Committee, whose members usually close ranks and staunchly defend the process for deciding CDS triggers in the face of media scrutiny. The criticism may also heighten concerns about a market already in a state of flux, with participants questioning the value of the instrument if Greek CDS does not trigger.”
"The SEAT vote didn't seem very independent in the way people were voting on legal merit versus their position," said one senior credit trader, whose firm sits on the DC. "How to enforce independent decision-making may not have been carefully thought out when the DC was set up. It's a concern that won't go away and will eventually come up in the context of Greece."
All participants agreed that the SEAT case was legally complex. The Italian firm's bonds were issued by a Luxembourg-based special-purpose vehicle, which had a loan agreement with SEAT. When a payment was missed, there was debate over whether the grace period of the bonds – 30 days – should be applied to the loan (which would have otherwise have had a three-day grace period).
The DC reached a deadlock of eight votes to seven, and the decision was sent for external review. This subsequently proved unnecessary: two days later the 30-day grace period expired and a credit event was agreed upon unanimously.
Despite the eventual CDS trigger, two firms with DC representation told IFR they were frustrated by the original decision and remained suspicious of other members' voting motives.”
In times when liquidity is tight, it is to be expected that such disputes will become more frequent, even if this one was in the end resolved to everyone's satisfaction.
In this particular case, Magritte would probably remind us that 'this is not a fountain'.
Ceci n'est pas une fontaine
it isn't even the picture of one! What you see here could be termed the
'treachery of upside-down urinals'.
(Painting by René Magritte)
A Few Papers on CDS For Download
For readers interested in the details of how CDS actually work, here is an extensive backgrounder from JP Morgan for download (pdf).
In addition, here is a somewhat more technical research paper that goes a bot further into the maths of calculating the value of CDS, default probabilities, etc. (pdf)
Lastly a paper on using fundamental analysis to explain variations in CDS prices and how such analysis can potentially be used to predict future moves in CDS spreads (pdf).
Greece's one year note yield as at the end of last week: at 328.7% it likely invites arbitrage with CDS on Greek debt.
Charts by: Bloomberg
It is that time of the year again – our semi-annual funding drive begins today. Give us a little hand in offsetting the costs of running this blog, as advertising revenue alone is insufficient. You can help us reach our modest funding goal by donating either via paypal or bitcoin. Those of you who have made a ton of money based on some of the things we have said in these pages (we actually made a few good calls lately!), please feel free to up your donations accordingly (we are sorry if you have followed one of our bad calls. This is of course your own fault). Other than that, we can only repeat that donations to this site are apt to secure many benefits. These range from sound sleep, to children including you in their songs, to the potential of obtaining privileges in the afterlife (the latter cannot be guaranteed, but it seems highly likely). As always, we are greatly honored by your readership and hope that our special mixture of entertainment and education is adding a little value to your life!
Bitcoin address: 1DRkVzUmkGaz9xAP81us86zzxh5VMEhNke
7 Responses to “Ceci N’est Pas Une Pipe – And It Ain’t A Fountain Either”
Most read in the last 20 days:
- A Date Which Will Live in Infamy
President Nixon’s Decision to Abandon the Gold Standard Franklin Delano Roosevelt called the Japanese “surprise” attack on the U.S. occupied territory of Hawaii and its naval base Pearl Harbor, “A Date Which Will Live in Infamy.” Similar words should be used for President Nixon’s draconian decision 45 years ago this month that removed America from the last vestiges of the gold standard. Nixon points out where numerous evil speculators were suspected to be...
- Insanity, Oddities and Dark Clouds in Credit-Land
Insanity Rules Bond markets are certainly displaying a lot of enthusiasm at the moment – and it doesn't matter which bonds one looks at, as the famous “hunt for yield” continues to obliterate interest returns across the board like a steamroller. Corporate and government debt have been soaring for years, but investor appetite for such debt has evidently grown even more. The perfect investment for modern times: interest-free risk! Illuustration by Howard...
- US Economy – Something is not Right
Another Strong Payrolls Report – is it Meaningful? This morning the punters in the casino were cheered up by yet another strong payrolls report, the second in a row. Leaving aside the fact that it will be revised out of all recognition when all is said and done, does it actually mean the economy is strong? Quo vadis, economy? Image credit: Paul Raphaelson As we usually point out at this juncture: apart from the problem that US labor force participation has...
- Trump's Tax Plan, Clinton Corruption and Mainstream Media Propaganda
Fake Money, Fake Capital OUZILLY, France – Little change in the markets on Monday. We are in the middle of vacation season. Who wants to think too much about the stock market? Not us! Yesterday, Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump promised to reform the U.S. tax system. This should actually even appeal to supporters of Bernie Sanders: the lowest income groups will be completely exempt from income and capital gains taxes under Trump's plan. We expect to hear...
- The Great Stock Market Swindle
Short Circuited Feedback Loops Finding and filling gaps in the market is one avenue for entrepreneurial success. Obviously, the first to tap into an unmet consumer demand can unlock massive profits. But unless there’s some comparative advantage, competition will quickly commoditize the market and profit margins will decline to just above breakeven. Example of a “commoditized” market – hard-drive storage costs per GB. This is actually the essence of economic...
- Bank of England QE and the Imaginary “Brexit Shock”
Mark Carney, Wrecking Ball For reasons we cannot even begin to fathom, Mark Carney is considered a “superstar” among central bankers. Presumably this was one of the reasons why the British government helped him to execute a well-timed exit from the Bank of Canada by hiring him to head the Bank of England (well-timed because he disappeared from Canada with its bubble economy seemingly still intact, leaving his successor to take the blame). This is how Mark Carney is seen by...
- An Old Friend Returns
A Rare Apparition An old friend suddenly showed up out of the blue yesterday and I’m not talking about a contributor who had washed out and, after years of ‘working for the man’, decided to return for another whack at beating the market. Instead I am delighted to report that I am looking at a bona fide confirmed VIX sell signal which we haven’t seen for ages here. Hello, old friend. Professor X and Magneto staring each other down in the plastic...
- The Fabian Society and the Gradual Rise of Statist Socialism
The “Third Way” “Stealth, intrigue, subversion, and the deception of never calling socialism by its right name” – George Bernard Shaw An emblem of the Fabian Society: a wolf in sheep's clothing The Brexit referendum has revealed the existence of a deep polarization in British politics. Apart from the public faces of the opposing campaigns, there were however also undisclosed parties with a vested interest which few people have heard about. And...
- News from TINA Land
Distortions and Crazy Ideas We have come across a few articles recently that discuss some of the strategies investors are using or contemplating to use as a result of the market distortions caused by current central bank policies. Readers have no doubt noticed that numerous inter-market correlations seem to have been suspended lately, and that many things are happening that superficially seem to make little sense (e.g. falling junk bond yields while defaults are surging; the yen rising...
- Retail Snails
Second Half Recovery Dented by “Resurgent Consumer” We normally don't comment in real time on individual economic data releases. Generally we believe it makes more sense to occasionally look at a bigger picture overview, once at least some of the inevitable revisions have been made. The update we posted last week (“US Economy, Something is Not Right”) is an example. Eager consumers storming a store Photo credit: Daniel Acker / Bloomberg We'll make an...
- The Fed’s “Waterloo” Moment
Corrupt and Unsustainable James has been a big help. Trying to get him to sleep at night, we have been telling him fantastic and unbelievable bedtime stories – full of grotesque monsters... evil maniacs... and events that couldn’t possibly be true (catch up here and here). He turned his head until his gaze came to rest on the barred windows of the main building. Finally, he spoke; as far as I was aware these were the first words he had uttered in more than five years....
- Good Money and Bad Money
Confidence Gets a Boost OUZILLY, France – Last week’s U.S. jobs report came in better than expected. Stocks rose to new records. As we laid out recently, a better jobs picture should lead the Fed to raise rates. This should cause canny investors to dump stocks. Canny investors at work (an old, but good one...) Cartoon via Pension Pulse But the stock market paid no attention. It follows logic of its own. Headlines told us that last Friday’s report “boosted...